26-09-25 Soil Remed & Tree Removal
September 25, 2026

September 25, 2026
After an exhaustive assessment of possible alternatives, the Pasadena Unified School District (PUSD) has had to make the difficult decision to remove several mature, protected trees on the front lawn of Longfellow Magnet School to complete the removal of contaminated soil found following the Eaton Fire. Tree removal will begin early next week, followed by excavation and soil disposal. The health and safety of our students and staff have remained our highest priority throughout this cleanup effort.
If a safe and workable way existed to preserve the Longfellow trees, fully address the contaminated soil, and return the property to unrestricted educational use, we would take it without hesitation. However, after an extensive assessment, we have concluded that, unfortunately, no such option exists within a reasonable timeframe to return students to campus safely.
At the same time, we are glad to share some encouraging progress at Blair High School. At last night’s Board of Education meeting, the Board approved a bioremediation agreement with the Center for Applied Ecological Remediation to treat a contaminated soil area at Blair containing two City-claimed protected trees. The work will take approximately eight months to complete, at no cost to the District. The Board also approved exploring funding for bioremediation of one additional contaminated soil area containing a City-claimed protected mature tree at Blair. We are pleased to be able to move forward with this remediation approach at Blair, and it reflects our ongoing commitment to protecting trees wherever conditions allow.
While bioremediation can be a valuable tool when contaminant levels are low enough and site conditions allow for gradual treatment, as is the case in certain areas at Blair, this is not the case at Longfellow. There, the lead concentrations, the location of the contamination, and the requirements of the state-overseen cleanup make bioremediation neither reliable nor feasible.
In addition, bioremediation, when it works, can also take years to show meaningful results, requiring the treated area to remain closed for student and teacher use until contaminants are reduced to safe levels in the soil. For the Longfellow elementary campus undergoing comprehensive modernization work, this timeline is neither a workable solution, nor are the contamination levels low enough to guarantee success.
We know that the tree removal news is hard to hear. We know exactly what trees mean to our PUSD community. They are large, familiar, and deeply connected to the character of the campus. They provide shade, beauty, and history that cannot simply be replaced overnight.
We Took Another Look
Earlier this month, PUSD committed to taking a fresh look at the arborist analysis before making a final decision regarding the remaining mature trees. And we did.
The original preliminary report was not as complete or explanatory as it should have been. In response to the extensive questions raised by community members, we asked the arborist to go back through the original field work, measurements, photographs, and observations from the August air-knifing assessment and more fully document the work that was performed and the basis for his conclusions.
The final attached report provides substantially more detail about the tree by tree evaluation performed during the assessment, including the locations and depths of air excavation, the depth at which structural roots were observed, the relationship between those roots and the contaminated soil, which was evaluated simultaneously by our environmental consultant, and the basis for the arborist’s conclusions.
This additional review and documentation did not change the central finding: that excavation to remove the contaminated soil, whether through air-knifing or other methods would impact the trees’ critical root systems and compromise their stability. Additionally, the arborist notes that several trees lean toward East Washington Boulevard. As a result, the arborist recommends removal rather than additional air-knifing or excavation around the trees.
Earlier this summer, the California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) reviewed the District’s latest front-lawn excavation analysis and confirmed that a significant quantity of contaminated soil remains within the critical root zones of these trees. In its August 31, 2026 letter, DTSC further stated that this soil, and “infrastructure, trees, and vegetation that impede removal of contaminated soil should be removed and replaced” for the site to receive a No Further Action determination and to support the state matching funds associated with the Longfellow modernization project.
Why Not Simply Cover the Contaminated Soil?
One alternative that has been suggested is leaving the contaminated soil in place and covering it with an impermeable barrier.
In practical terms, that would mean converting the affected green space into a permanently capped area, likely a hard surface such as concrete or asphalt, so students, staff, and the community could not come into contact with the contaminated soil underneath and reduce or eliminate the risk of airborne dust exposure.
This would preserve the trees only by leaving the contamination permanently where it is. In other words, it would simply manage the environmental issue, and contamination would remain on school property at levels not safe for use by children. The DTSC would also require a recorded land use covenant or similar institutional controls governing the campus.
A land use covenant is more than a document acknowledging that contamination once existed. It is a continuing restriction created because contamination still exists.
Depending on the final restrictions approved for a particular site, requirements for environmental review or soil management procedures before future excavation or construction, continuing inspection and reporting obligations, and ongoing DTSC oversight would be required for the school to operate. In other words, there would be limitations and controls any time soil is disturbed to repair utilities, install landscaping, and perform modernization work. There would also be substantial initial and ongoing annual costs. And future generations would have to work around that contamination, ultimately facing the same decision PUSD faces today.
PUSD believes the better long-term choice is to remove the contaminated soil now instead of knowingly leaving it beneath a newly modernized Longfellow campus for future generations to address.
Why not air-knife?
Air-knifing was specifically used because the Board directed the District to explore reasonable ways to preserve mature trees.
The technique uses compressed air and vacuum excavation to carefully expose roots while minimizing damage. It allowed the arborist and environmental team to determine where major structural roots were located and how they intersected with the contaminated soil.
Unfortunately, the air-knifing showed that the critical roots and the contaminated soil are comingled, and continuing to remove contaminated soil around the trees would no longer be a preservation strategy. It would remove the support that keeps our trees stable, ultimately resulting in failure of the trees.
Replanting and Canopy Restoration
PUSD is committed to planting at least one replacement tree for every tree removed. Replacement planting will follow the District’s 2026 Landscape and Exterior Space Guidelines, which incorporate current fire-resilient design principles and approved plant palettes emphasizing native, drought-tolerant, and locally adapted species, as well as trees selected to provide meaningful long-term shade for students.
This is part of a broader commitment the Board adopted on August 27, 2026: to preserve and expand PUSD’s existing tree canopy and to work toward at least 30 percent mature tree canopy coverage in outdoor areas used for student learning, play, and circulation by 2035. The resolution also directs the District to use its landscape guidelines and approved plant palettes to guide tree selection, placement, irrigation, and long-term care, and calls for annual updates to the tree inventory and public reporting on progress.
We know that replacing a tree does not replace what was lost. That’s why the District is also working to preserve something tangible from these trees. Our team is gathering seedlings and other viable plant materials where possible to propagate them at other sites. We have also reached out to community organizations and lumber companies to repurpose usable wood so that something lasting and meaningful comes from the trees.
A Difficult Decision, Guided by Student Safety
We understand that some members of our community will still disagree with this decision, and we understand why. No one is happy about removing mature trees that have defined the front of Longfellow Magnet School for generations. The aftermath of the Eaton Fire left PUSD facing conditions we did not create and choices we never wanted to make.
Student safety has to come first, and it has guided every part of this decision. After an exhaustive review of the environmental requirements, the arborist’s findings, the available preservation alternatives, and the long-term consequences of leaving contamination in place, we have concluded that removal is the most responsible path forward. This conclusion reflects the District’s responsibility to address the contamination fully and protect the students who will learn and play on this campus for decades to come.
Their safety has to be our first priority.
Once the remediation is complete, PUSD will restore the affected area and replant trees as part of our broader commitment to preservation, replacement, and long-term canopy growth across District campuses.
For more information, please visit pusd.us/restoringourschools.
###