The Welsh School Improvement Battle
Professional learning for schools is in chaos in Wales
The education system in Wales is in chaos. Those tasked with supporting school improvement are in a fight for their lives and it's not going to be pretty for anyone. As with so many political fights the thing that sits at the bottom of all this is, power.
In January of last year, Welsh Government published the results of phase one of the Middle Tier Review. The letter from Professor Dylan Jones set out how inconsistent and ineffective headteachers felt the regional consortia support for school improvement had been across the country. Whilst the support was deemed excellent in pockets, this level of excellence was not available consistently enough across the country. The letter stated, “a clear majority of LAs are in favour of exploring a move away from current arrangements for regional support or have already moved away from it.”
Let’s take a moment to understand why this might have happened. Back in 2012 local authorities and schools were told they were no longer in charge of the school improvement in their area. Four new regional professional bodies would be doing that. This in part was due to the Williams Commission Report which recommended that Wales’ local authorities should be reduced from 22 to just 8 or 9. When Welsh Government could see that LAs would dig their heels in and refuse to be reduced in number, one way this could be circumnavigated for education services, would be to create 4 regional bodies to work directly with schools on professional learning. This fix was to prove a highly complicated and complex one.
Professional learning wasn’t the only thing that regional consortia started doing, they also had a pretty robust challenge arm to their work. Challenge Advisors as they were initially called, were tasked with challenging schools and local authorities on the quality of education being provided. Local authorities were now in the impossible position of being legally accountable for the quality of education and schools deemed as being a cause for concern, but having no direct control over the guidance and support those schools might be receiving to help them improve. Support for the school would be a matter of negotiation between the local authority and the regional consortia.
This power sharing arrangement seems to have suited no-one and, unfortunately where standards have suffered it has been felt most keenly by schools and their pupils.
Now, we are in a position where regional consortia will cease to exist under their current format, or in some cases, at all. So, what has happened to that power, who now will be taking control of school improvement for schools in Wales? And will those new arrangements be any better for schools?
Cabinet Secretary for education, Lynne Neagle is not taking any more chances with school improvement. She’s decided that the power that has resided in regional consortia since their inception in 2012, should not be simply shared out amongst the local authorities, but it should largely come back to Welsh Government.
There’s a new, central, national professional learning body that is working on a “Once for Wales” approach to professional learning for schools. There’s also Adnodd the new, central, professional learning resources limited company, which is fully funded by Welsh Government. Ms Neagle has also announced a new Ministerial Expert Advisory Group, which is a team of experts who will meet quarterly just to advise her. There’s a new Expert Literacy Panel, another new group focused on central decision making around literacy. And if that wasn't enough she's also announced a Ministerial Headteachers Advisory Group, paid at £300 a day, the closing date for applications being April 11th. But most interesting of all, is the new internal, Welsh Government School Improvement Team, whose role is to “lead more regular strategic engagement with local authorities, share national priorities, developing cross-sector understanding and provide national support as appropriate.”
That's five new central bodies, or groups. Five new organisations to replace the five regional consortia.
At the head of these groups is the new internal WG school improvement team, who are leading the new partnership working between local authorities. The power for school improvement has been re-centralised. Just like the process of moving to a new or bigger house, this movement of professional learning or re-centralisation has come at a cost. The Local Authority Education Grant has been reduced for 2025-26 to pay for the new central bodies and teams. So local authorities already have less money than consortia had to deliver a better service. The timeline for change is also extremely challenging. Welsh Government have appointed former education minister, Kirsty Williams to lead a new Coherence Group to make sure “all schools in Wales are participating in purposeful vertical AND horizontal collaborative approaches and structures focused on improving learning by April 2026.” Not long then to completely restructure the whole professional learning landscape in Wales.
How exactly this will happen is still very unclear.
What seems to have been forgotten is that many of the consortia staff have been cast adrift. There are many advisors and other staff using the “open to work offers” tag on LinkedIn, their future is unsure. The managing director of Central South Consortium, Clara Seery, arguably the most successful of the four consortia, jumped ship to a MAT in England in September 2024. Indeed, in minutes of a recent CSC meeting a significant underspend within their budget was attributed to problems recruiting staff to consortia roles. How many more good quality school improvement staff will be lost from the Welsh system before this power struggle settles?
There are also signs from LA meeting minutes that the fate of the five current regional consortia is at best uncertain, at worst their disbandment will actually cost LA budgets. GWE the consortia for North Wales has been dealing with the cost of making staff who are not moving directly to LAs redundant. This has left them in a deficit of £919k, which they hope will be funded by Welsh Government, but if not councils themselves will have to fund the gap.
Partneriaeth notes in their recent risk register, that the lack of clarity around the functions of their organisation has a medium probability and a high impact, whereas not receiving enough money from the LAs they serve to enable them to provide effective school improvement support is labelled a medium probability with a very high impact.
The chaos that has been the inevitable result of removing the regional consortia school improvement model at short notice, with limited forward planning, is a real and ongoing risk to school improvement in Wales. How will the 1, 415 schools in Wales improve, if there is only one central team in a position to support them?
A recent piece of news which brings the quality of school improvement across Wales into sharp focus is what has been going on in Powys. The recent report by Estyn on school improvement services in Powys states: "leadership at all levels has had a limited impact on securing important improvements in education services or in improving outcomes for children and young people. Inspection outcomes in secondary and all-age schools have been poor over time. Since the last Local Government Education Services inspection in 2019, only two secondary schools have not required any level of follow-up. Whilst primary school inspections have been more positive, a larger proportion of primary schools have been placed into follow-up since February 2021 than we generally see nationally."
Powys have been working in a partnership with Ceredigion since the dissolution of ERW in March 2021, which was essentially forced by Neath Port Talbot refusing to continue to fund the regional school improvement service. Which brings us neatly back to where this power struggle began.
Whilst this battle for control between local councils and Welsh Government is raging, schools are still going about the day job. School improvement still needs to happen. Headteachers still need to provide professional learning that supports their staff to improve. But, if the quality of what is being provided during this transition period to help schools, is taking an inevitable nose dive, what does this mean for the quality of education being provided in Wales?
We're sure that everyone involved in this monumental struggle for control of school improvement, no matter what their role, wants the same thing, the best education for our children. But it feels like there is no way out of this brawl. We have to see the fight that was started in 2021, right through to the bitter end. We just hope that what emerges from the battlefield is a body of people who have the expertise, experience and freedom to provide schools with the expert school improvement support they truly deserve.
If you’d like to find out how we can partner with you to build professional learning that supports your school to improve, click the button below to contact us.
A Little More About Us:
Who are we? - We are Finola & Jane, Literacy & Numeracy specialists, with 45+ years of teaching, training & leadership experience between us.
What's our experience? - We have both worked for Welsh Government supporting schools & senior leaders across Wales. We have held senior leadership posts, delivered support to strategic education advisers, both hold school governor posts and have published curriculum support guidance with Oxford University Press...but if you need to know more visit our website for testimonials from schools we've worked with.
Why should you book our support? - Put simply, because we believe in impact. We do exactly what our name suggests. Our workshop keeps things simple and ensures school actions really work. Our focus is always on delivering measurable impact for pupils
Email: enquiries@impact.wales
Website: www.impact.wales
Phone: 02921 679140
Facebook: facebook.com/impactwales123
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/11229163/admin/dashboard/
Providing support to schools that has real impact