The Center for Teaching & Learning
April 8, 2025
From the CTL Director
My colleague, Emily Belknap, who is very wise, has a note on her desk with this reminder: Never stand in the way of someone else’s learning. I think about this a lot this time of year, particularly as I’m meeting with students who have very specific asks: 10 empirical articles on the impact of burnout on ICU nurses, 12 articles about fashion in 1960s Japan, a set of interconnected primary sources from the late eighteenth century that include encrypted clues to an underground chamber full of gold trinkets—okay, that last one was the plot of National Treasure, but you get the picture. These are motivated students who understand the what of the assignment, but who don’t always yet understand the how or, importantly, the why.
In our neverending quest for "student success," we sometimes want to ferry students across the finish line before they're ready. We want to ward off failure and frustration. But learning--especially big, transformative learning--is frustrating. I remind myself of this when I’m meeting with a student, and they’re struggling, and they would be so delighted if I could just email them the links and citations to 15 articles on the sleeping habits of snails. On one hand, I would love to just solve that problem for them. But, as I remind myself: we don’t stand in the way of someone else’s learning.
In order to not stand in the way of someone else’s learning, we have to be patient. We have to remind students (and ourselves) that frustration is a part of the process. But it's a tightrope walk. How much should we let students struggle before we step in? When are we giving students tools to succeed, and when are we doing the succeeding for them? And how much of our work is artfully setting a kind of educational mise en place: not preventing frustration, but putting supports in place so that students feel like they can learn through the frustration?
This issue of the CTL newsletter has lots to explore. I appreciate Sangeeta Gupta’s approach to mitigating conflict in group work, as well as her acknowledgement that some conflict is unavoidable and even important. I'm going to use image cueing , which I learned from Ashley Coen's article, in an upcoming class. And finally, Kathryn Ryberg addresses an incredibly important topic: how to notice and address several common biases, both in ourselves and others.
One final reminder: the last CTL event of the spring semester is Software Palooza, this Friday, April 11, from 2-4 PM, on the second floor of the library. Like any good palooza, Software Palooza will have snacks, drinks, door prizes, free swag, and the dulcet tones of ‘90s alternative rock wafting through the library. But unlike most paloozas you’ve attended, Software Palooza gives you a chance to try out all the coolest educational technology: from Blackboard Ultra to Adobe to IIIF to screen recording tools to AI research tools AND MORE. You're welcome to attend the (short) sessions or just hang out and try out new technology. I hope to see you there!
Friday, April 11: SOFTWARE PALOOZA!
🎵💻👨🏻💻🎉 SOFTWARE PALOOZA! 🎪🍕🍺💻
Friday, April 11, 2:00-4:00 PM; Second floor of the Beneficial-Hodson Library
RSVP here: https://bit.ly/ctlrsvp
Schedule
Main Stage (Library 2006)
2 - 2:30 PM: Welcome & Blackboard Ultra Presentation
3 - 3:30 PM: Adobe Suite Presentation
The Pit (Open Areas on the 2nd Floor of the Library)
2:30 - 3 PM, 3:30 - 4 PM
- Creative Projects Using IIIF with Adelmar Ramirez
- Generative AI Research Tools with Jessica Hammack
- Engaging Students Asynchronously (with screen recording!) with Jeff Welsh
- Classroom Polling with Kelly Esposito
The VIP Lounge (Library 2028)
2-4 PM
Food, drinks, workshopping ideas, general merriment
Monday, April 21: SPIRES
Making Group Work Work
Sangeeta Gupta, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Psychology
Group work – when gone awry – can be a nightmare. We’ve all been there—stuck in a mismatched team where one person takes control of everything, another disappears until presentation day, and the rest hover somewhere in between. But when managed well, group work can also become an invaluable opportunity for skill-building, collaboration, and personal growth. The challenge for us as educators is to design group work that goes beyond just checking a box—it should be a true learning experience. By thoughtfully considering how we form groups, setting clear group norms and communication practices, and incorporating peer evaluations, we can help students transform what might feel like a frustrating task into a meaningful collaboration. Through these strategies, we lay the foundation for a productive and supportive group work environment that fosters genuine learning.
1. Group Formation: The key to successful group work is how groups are formed. While self-selecting or random assignment can both work well for short-term projects, longer-term projects tend to require more upfront planning. In my research methods classes, where students work with the same group for two semesters, I send a survey to students to assess their working styles and, more importantly, their grade expectations. I remind them that not everyone cares equally about earning an A in research methods, and I ask them questions to capture this range of priorities. Understanding where students fall on this spectrum helps me create groups with aligned expectations.
2. Group norms and expectations: Establishing clear group agreements early on can significantly improve collaboration. I encourage students to set expectations together—discussing things like communication preferences, deadlines, and how they’ll handle disagreements. These agreements help everyone feel more accountable and create a sense of shared responsibility, making it easier to navigate challenges as a team. When students co-create their group norms, they’re more likely to buy into them and work toward a common goal. During points of conflict through the semester, I encourage them to refer back to these norms that they created.
3. Central communication streams: Another key to successful group work is establishing a central communication stream. I use Microsoft Teams to keep all project-related conversations, documents, and updates in one place. This way, students can easily collaborate, share resources, and track progress without the confusion of scattered emails or messages. I also require my students to track changes on shared documents, so I can monitor individual contributions. This transparency helps ensure accountability and allows me to see who has contributed what, making it easier to address any issues that may arise throughout the project.
4. Formal group meetings: Throughout the semester, I schedule regular formal group meetings (we call them “lab meetings”) to keep group work on track. During these meetings, they discuss their progress, set goals for the coming week, and address any challenges. These meetings are documented via graded lab meeting notes so there’s a clear record of what was discussed and decided. Having this written documentation helps hold everyone accountable, ensures that no one falls behind, and provides a point of reference if any issues arise later. It also allows me to check in periodically and offer guidance, ensuring that the project stays on course throughout the term.
5. Peer Evaluations: At key points throughout the project, I ask students to assess their teammates’ contributions. This not only encourages students to reflect on their own work and that of others, but it also provides valuable feedback on how the group is functioning. Peer evaluations can highlight areas for improvement and help identify any issues with workload distribution or communication early on. This process also reinforces the importance of collaboration and ensures that everyone’s contributions are recognized, creating a more balanced and fair assessment of the group’s work.
But I do want to set the record straight. Despite my best intentions and careful consideration of all the strategies I’ve outlined, I have never had a conflict-free semester (or a conflict-free week at some points in the semester!). Groups, by their very nature, tend to bring together diverse perspectives, working styles, and priorities, which inevitably leads to some level of tension or disagreement. However, I often remind myself and my students that this is not a bad thing. Conflict, when addressed constructively, can be an opportunity for growth, learning, and strengthening collaboration skills. The key is in creating an environment where students feel empowered to navigate these challenges, and giving them the tools and support to work through them.
Activating Prior Knowledge to Support Student Learning
Ashley Coen, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Education
This year, my colleagues in the Department of Education and I have been collaborating with teachers and administrators from FCPS, as well as researchers from the education nonprofit Deans for Impact, to develop best practices for supporting both pre-service and in-service teachers in leveraging students' prior knowledge for deep, lasting learning. Our work builds on Willingham’s Model of the Mind (2009) to suggest that students learn more effectively when prompted to retrieve relevant prior knowledge from long-term memory and use it to process new information. When students recognize connections between concepts and structure information meaningfully, they enhance comprehension and reduce cognitive load.
However, we cannot assume that students will make these connections on their own; they need structured opportunities to link what they already know with new learning. Educators can support their students by drawing attention to relevant prior knowledge and explicitly demonstrating its relationship to new content. When done in a way that includes all students in a classroom, this approach fosters more equitable learning experiences by ensuring that every student can build on a strong foundation in the content.
Our partners at Deans for Impact recommend three instructional routines to support prior knowledge activation. The first, image cueing, involves using an evocative image to surface relevant prior knowledge, which students then discuss or write about. The second, graphic organizers, involves providing students with a set of relevant words or ideas from prior learning and prompting students to map the relationships between these key concepts. The third, funds of knowledge, connects new learning to students’ family, cultural, and community experiences. Additionally, they caution against techniques that are too broad, fail to engage all learners, or neglect to evaluate the relevance of the prior knowledge being surfaced.
While our work focuses on current and future preK–12 teachers, these strategies can also support learning in the college classroom. If you would like to learn more, please feel free to reach out!
Better Thinking Through Bias Awareness
Kathryn Ryberg, M.A., M.L.I.S., Research & Instruction Librarian
We all have biases. Biases can lead to prejudices, believing in conspiracy theories, or doubting one’s own judgement. Unfortunately, biases can be very difficult to overcome, but awareness is a start. Below are some brief outlines of biases you may encounter. Remember that changing beliefs can be challenging, so give some latitude to yourself and others.
All-or-none thinking or Dichotomous thinking
People who exhibit this tendency believe that all issues have only two sides, right and wrong, black or white. This bias may be the result of high stress or social isolation, both of which tend to exacerbate the bias by providing reinforcing feedback.
Example: Those who engage in climate change denial reduce the vast array of scientific evidence into 100% agreement or no agreement whatsoever.
How to address it: Countering this bias revolves around being able to tolerate ambiguity or admitting that there is a grey area to accommodate some situations. This involves “intellectual humility” and being able to recalibrate your beliefs when presented with contradictory evidence. If you talk with someone exhibiting this bias, listen with empathy and encourage them to think of alternative explanations (Scheffer et al., 2022, “A More Generic Approach”, para. 2).
Confirmation Bias
People prefer to feel that their beliefs are right and will seek out information that aligns with those beliefs. Ignoring or discounting contrary information are other symptoms of this bias. Some beliefs may be part of an individual’s identity, and such entrenched views may resist change.
Example: People who believe in conspiracy theories, like QAnon or Plandemic, engage with like-minded individuals and disseminate information that confirms their support of these theories.
How to address it: Although many people may be resistant to changing their views in the face of contrasting information, one study found that considering opposing information against their own perspectives can encourage belief updates. This “metacognitive reflection” may make one address uncertainty within their own beliefs and thereby become more receptive to changing their views (O’Leary & Fletcher, 2024, “Discussion”, para. 3).
Automation Bias
Automation bias results from the tendency for people to let their guard down and trust machines. People may feel that machines are accurate, objective and infallible or even polite and trustworthy. This bias becomes even more robust if the systems exhibit aspects of humanity like the conversational language used by many AIs.
Example: One study found that doctors ignored their own correct diagnoses, instead favoring the incorrect ones provided by an automated diagnostic system (Goddard et al., 2012, p. 121).
How to address it: People should be willing to vet AI responses against one’s own knowledge or verify the information with a reliable source. Correcting misinformation in social media contexts can be helpful, as can users taking full responsibility for decision making in medical, judicial or other professional settings (Alon-Barkat & Busuioc, 2023, p. 166; Bode & Varga, 2018, p. 1136).
Works Cited
Alon-Barkat, S., & Busuioc, M. (2023). Human–AI interactions in public sector decision making: “Automation bias” and “selective adherence” to algorithmic advice. Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory, 33(1), 153–169. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/muac007
Bode, L., & Vraga, E. K. (2018). See something, say something: Correction of global health misinformation on social media. Health Communication, 33(9), 1131–1140. https://doi.org/10.1080/10410236.2017.1331312
Goddard, K., Roudsari, A., & Wyatt, J. C. (2012). Automation bias: A systematic review of frequency, effect mediators, and mitigators. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association: JAMIA, 19(1), 121–127. https://doi.org/10.1136/amiajnl-2011-000089
O’Leary, A. P., & Fletcher, W. (2024). Thinking about believing: Can metacognitive reflection encourage belief updating? Journal of Intelligence, 12(5), 47. https://doi.org/10.3390/jintelligence12050047
Scheffer, M., Borsboom, D., Nieuwenhuis, S., & Westley, F. (2022). Belief traps: Tackling the inertia of harmful beliefs. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119(32), e2203149119. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2203149119
What Does the GA Say? A Student's Perspective
Kelly Esposito, MAH Student
In researching what CTLs at various institutions do and why, I came across an interesting article titled “Maslow’s Hierarchy and Student Retention” written by David M. Brookman and published in 1989. There is nothing shocking in this article. In sharing ways to increase retention, Dr. Brookman illuminates that students need their more basic needs met before they can focus on self-actualization. It’s no shock that students who feel unsafe or unconnected find it a struggle in school. School is pretty meaningless when compared to safety and connection. But doesn’t this apply to everyone including staff and faculty? How can the CTL serve as a conduit of modern pedagogical ideas when our students—the teaching staff and faculty—are feeling unsafe or unconnected?
Regardless of your political views, teaching style, teaching schedule, or number of students you are teaching at Hood College, that commonality of teaching should be enough to open a door to discussion and a movement toward increased community. For the same reasons Hood College promotes student activities and involvement it should promote activities and involvement for teaching staff and faculty. The CTL functions as a glorious combination of information resource administration and party planner. Think of the CTL as a pedagogic focused Book It! event.
When it seems like the end of the academic world is imminent, it feels much easier to sit down and just let it happen. Don’t do it! Reinvigorate yourself and your classroom by participating in our next CTL event. Chat with your community members from a different department, learn about a new website or teaching method, or get tips from peers about managing stress or student apathy in the classroom. If you can’t focus on meeting new people or learning something new, then join CTL to feel the community vibe and replenish yourself.
If you would like to learn more about CTL and our mission look for our poster at the SPIRE Symposium!
Tiny Tidbits
"Those who can, do. Those who understand, teach."
These words are sometimes misattributed to Aristotle but were used by Lee S. Shulman in his 1986 article "Those Who Understand: Knowledge Growth in Teaching." The more derogatory version of this "He who can, does. He who cannot, teaches" has been attributed to George Bernard Shaw's play Man and Superman but even this attribution seems suspect.
Shulman, Lee S. “Those Who Understand: Knowledge Growth in Teaching.” Educational Researcher 15.2 (1986): 4–14. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1175860
Search for Jobs and Meaning
You can find more information about the model that Boyer developed here which includes SoTL (Scholarship of Teaching and Learning).
Lightbulb Lessons
Take a lesson from the longest burning lightbulb. Sometimes burning a little less brightly will allow you to burn consistently for a longer period of time. Here are a few new suggestions for intentionally slowing down.
Now Available: Teaching the Virtues
Professor Emeritus David Hein's new book Teaching the Virtues is out from Mecosta House. You can purchase a copy or check it out in the faculty section of Hood's library.
Upcoming Webinars
April Lunch & Learn: Maintaining Commitment to Equity & Mission in a Polarized Context
Sponsored by Transform Mid-Atlantic
At a time when government and media are scrutinizing and limiting academic freedom and higher education institutional autonomy, campus leaders need tactics and strategies to navigate policies and politics that may interfere with their institutional missions.
This Lunch & Learn will provide concrete measures which can help reduce the chilling effect on institutional culture while aligning internal and external stakeholders toward the college’s mission. Participants will leave with an action plan for their institutions to navigate their context.
Date & Time: Wednesday, April 16 | 12:00–1:00 PM ET
Location: Virtual via WebEx
Cost: This event is free and open to the public.
Registration Required: Registration link
Enhancing Critical Thinking with GenAI
Co-sponsored by the College Teaching and Learning Science graduate program and the Faculty Development Center at UMBC.
The AI revolution is here: Are your teaching methods evolving?
We're inviting you to join the discussion!
This free webinar is sponsored by the College Teaching Program at UMBC and will feature research findings using GenAI in the classroom.
Date & Time: Wednesday, April 23 | 12:00–1:30 PM ET
Location: Virtual via WebEx
Cost: This event is free and open to the public.
Join a CTL Community of Practice!
Communities of practice are groups of practitioners who share a common interest or knowledge who meet regularly to learn, grow, and build community.
The Center for Teaching and Learning wants to support your working groups, book discussion groups, teaching observation circles, and more. If you've got an idea that contributes to CTL's mission, then CTL wants to contribute to your idea.
During the times your community of practice meets, you can charge a lunch at the dining hall or snacks from the library café to the Center for Teaching and Learning. Here's how:
- Join an existing CTL community of practice below. If you're interested in joining a CoP, email the coordinator to learn more.
- Start your own CTL community of practice by completing and submitting the CTL CoP form. All communities of practice must be open to all faculty and staff and contribute to the mission of Hood's Center for Teaching and Learning.
Questions? Email ctl@hood.edu.
Spring 2025 Communities of Practice
Faculty Writing Group
Meeting time: Wednesdays at 2:50-5 PM in the Beneficial-Hodson Library
Coordinator: Kristen Tzoc (tzoc@hood.edu)
Join the Spring '25 faculty writing group every Wednesday from 2:30-5pm in Room 2020 of the Beneficial-Hodson Library! We meet weekly to create a shared sense of community, build accountability partnerships, and encourage and motivate one another as we work on our articles, grant proposals, conference applications, syllabi, reviews, and other writing-related tasks. If you'd like to join the group, please email Kristen Tzoc (tzoc@hood.edu) for the Outlook Calendar invite. Snacks provided!
Teaching Information Literacy
Meeting times: First Wednesday of each month from 1-2 PM; Coblentz Dining Hall
Coordinator: Jessica Hammack (hammack@hood.edu)
No matter what discipline you teach, you're teaching information literacy. It's in your reading assignments, your research assignments, your classroom discussions. It's in the scrolling your students are doing during your classroom discussions. Join librarians and disciplinary instructors in conversations about best practices in teaching information literacy: from crafting inquiry-based assignments to helping students engage critically in an information environment that is increasingly questionable.
This CoP is connected to the "Teaching Information Literacy at Ohio State" virtual workshops. Participation in the virtual workshops is optional, but conversations will center around the content of the previous month's workshops.
Statement of Support for Justice and Equity
The Center for Teaching and Learning condemns all forms of systemic racism, bias, and aggression against Black people, indigenous peoples, people of color, and those of marginalized genders and other marginalized identities. We understand that excellence in teaching, by definition, must reflect our shared humanity and promote inclusive practices such as:
- being conscious of biases, racial abuse, micro-aggressions, and those who are minimized or left out;
- understanding and supporting those underrepresented in our Hood community; and
- promoting ways to actively foster equity, diversity and inclusion in our classrooms, research, and publications.
The CTL advisory board is committed to raising awareness of all those who have been systematically oppressed, and we call upon Hood faculty and staff to join us in this commitment to create a more inclusive world.
Join the CTL Zotero Group!
View the CTL Library: https://www.zotero.org/groups/5620207/hood_ctl/library
Help us build the CTL library! Email ctl@hood.edu to be added as a contributor.
Want unlimited access The Chronicle of Higher Education? Access it through the library.
The library also has a section of books dedicated to teaching on the second floor.
- Jessica Hammack, Head of Research and Instruction, CTL Director
- April Boulton, Associate Professor of Biology, Associate Provost, Dean of the Graduate School
- Cathy Breneman, Assistant Professor of Social Work
- Ashley Coen, Assistant Professor of Education
- Sangeeta Gupta, Assistant Professor of Psychology
- Bridget Humphries, Director of Accessibility Services
- Beth Kiester, Associate Professor of Sociology
- Jessica McManus, Associate Professor of Psychology
- Heather Mitchell-Buck, Associate Professor of English, Coordinator of Digital Learning
- Nicole Pulichene, Libman Professor of Humanities
- Adelmar Ramirez, Assistant Professor of Spanish and Latin American Literature
- Kathryn Ryberg, Research & Instruction Librarian
- Sandra Thomas-Lalmansingh, Assistant Professor of Nursing
- Kristen Tzoc, Assistant Professor of Sociology
- Jeff Welsh, Director of Instructional Technology in the IT division
- Kelly Esposito, CTL Graduate Assistant
The Center for Teaching & Learning
Email: CTL@hood.edu
Website: www.hood.edu/CTL
Location: Hood College, 401 Rosemont Avenue, Frederick, MD
Phone: (301) 696-3397