Smore logo
remove_red_eye 3
page background
page background

Before You Grade a Card

Four checks and the math

Before You Grade aCardFour checks and the math

Grading is a decision about numbers, not about how much you like a card. Before you send one off, work out what the graded copy is really worth next to the raw card in your hand today.

Start with the raw price. Look up the exact set, card number and print year, not only the character name. A holographic from a base-era set and the same card reprinted years later can share a name and sit hundreds of dollars apart. Write down what raw copies sold for last month, then what the PSA 9 and PSA 10 versions of that same print sold for. The gap between those two numbers is the entire reason to grade.

Then count the costs that eat the gap: the grading fee at the service level you pick, shipping both ways, insurance on the way to the grader, and the fee you pay when the slab finally sells. Add the weeks your money sits in transit and in the grader queue. Subtract all of it and you have a real number, and sometimes it is smaller than you hoped. Finding that out before you buy is the point of the exercise.

Four things decide most of the outcome:

  • Corners: the four tips show damage first - dings, whitening, pressure marks from a tight sleeve.
  • Surfacing: scratches and dulling on the printed side; a few hairlines under a lamp can cost a grade.
  • Centering: front and back borders both count, and a clean card can still grade down for off-centre borders.
  • Print and focus: blurred printing or a crease through the card does not hide once a grader looks closely.

A cheap card with sharp corners and a clean surface is worth a submission for the practice it gives you. An expensive card with a corner ding usually is not: you already paid for the raw copy, and a middling grade rarely brings the difference back.

Timing matters as much as condition. Prices move with set rotations, tournament results, new releases and the season. A card that jumped when restock news broke often drifts back down, so check the price on the day you decide, not the day you saved it.

Two habits keep the math honest. Use one print for every comparison - raw, PSA 9 and PSA 10 of the identical set and number. And keep a plain log: what you paid, what grade came back, what it sold for. Your next decision should use your own numbers.

If you are learning the process, a free PSA grading calculator lets you enter your own card and see the numbers at grade 8, 9 and 10 after fees, shipping and selling costs. Greedy TCG also publishes a guide on how to get Pokemon cards graded, and a free Pokemon card price checker with raw and PSA 9 and 10 values for more than 41,000 cards. More at greedytcg.com.

This is general information for sellers, not investment advice.

Greedy TCG
Greedy is using Smore to create beautiful newsletters
Loading indicator

close

Created with

Communicate quickly and effectively with interactive newsletters.

Smore empowers educators to connect with their community, streamline school communications,
and increase engagement.

Create a newsletter