BUSD News
Update
June 28, 2022
State Audit Update
Bellflower Unified School District recently completed an audit review requested by two community legislators. Bellflower USD respects the efforts of the state auditor, particularly as it is part of California’s efforts for responsible fiscal practices and procedures at all levels of government, cities, housing, education, counties, courts, government operations and state programs, not just school districts. Mastering the intricacies of all these different agencies, with unique rules, operations, goals and purposes, schools and school districts among them, is a challenge for any auditor. And context is important, as the state auditor’s goal is to help individuals and organizations to improve. As the state auditor offers on its website, “the only way we can fulfill our mission is by working together, supporting each other, and always improving as individuals and as an organization.” Audits like this offer perspectives to be considered in an effort to improve, and are not alarming or punitive in nature.
WORKING TOGETHER
Bellflower USD fully cooperated with the auditors during the entire nearly eight-month process. That included meeting with various support and administrative staff, and supplementing further auditor requests through phone conferences and submission of documents. No responsive information or records were withheld. The draft audit was released on June 21, 2022. The District had five days to respond to a proposed audit report that took the auditor team of six individuals close to eight months to prepare. The District Superintendent and senior staff expedited efforts to provide a timely response and clarification of issues within that abbreviated period. While respecting the auditor’s efforts, the District wanted to respond out of concerns as to the basis for the auditor’s opinions and assumptions in the draft report which had not been fully explored with the District. The public audit report was released June 23, 2022.
CONCERNS ABOUT RESERVE LEVEL
One of the biggest areas of concern for the auditors was the District’s reserve level. The District recognizes it has a healthy cash reserve and prides itself in continuing to be prepared for unexpected events, a lesson reinforced by last minute adjustments required during the pandemic. The purpose of a healthy cash reserve is to assist during financial emergencies and ensure that our schools continue to operate in whatever way is feasible without our students and employees being negatively impacted to the extent humanly possible. Those reserves were of vital importance during the pandemic, coming out of it, and in experiencing student enrollment fluctuations on which state funding is based.
WHY STRONG RESERVES ARE IMPORTANT
Strong reserves are also essential for continued services and stabilizing the fiscal condition of Districts when navigating during revenue fluctuations. For example, when the pandemic closed schools down, many Districts immediately focused on eliminating any service expenditures they no longer were providing. Bellflower Unified took a different approach, paying all of our employees on an average of what they normally earned even though they were not working the extra hours. Recognizing the importance of good teachers and staff to consistent educational performance, Bellflower Unified wanted to make sure they remained committed to our students and available once schools reopened. This was done for a limited time with an understanding that reserves may be needed to cover the expense if state revenues did not come through. We also quickly looked for a way to get internet access to families that didn’t have access and paid for the services on their behalf to support continued educational and community services. These decisions were made despite the District not being sure about its funding revenue since Districts are funded based on Average Daily Attendance (ADA).
Having a healthy reserve also helps the community save when they are in favor of passing a bond. While the District has only passed one bond in its entire history, because of our healthy reserve, we received an A+ rating which resulted in cost savings to taxpayers. This is similar to a FICO score and allows you as a consumer to obtain a lower interest rate.
SOUND PRACTICES
Districts cannot obtain healthy reserves without having sound practices. Reserves are also public funds. We do use a conservative approach and our sites do an outstanding job of budgeting based on identified needs. All categorical funding which is considered restricted and helps provide supplemental services to students identified are used to the fullest. The District is also very proactive when it comes to grants and working with community partners to protect the use of unrestricted funds. Just recently, we were awarded the CalSHAPE grant for $1,137,902.40 which will help with repairs to our ventilation systems. This is an example of how the District uses grants to pay for costs that would normally be paid out of general funds, allowing those funds to be reserved for other needs. While the auditors felt, as is their right, that what you budget should be what you spend each year, in changing times you budget for worst case scenarios and spend as needed to meet educational, student and community needs. While we spent less than budgeted, every dime of those reserves stays with Bellflower USD and goes to stabilizing services and programs for present and future student needs. Unlike some schools, Bellflower USD does not budget to be out of money at year end, but to plan for every conceivable need in a manner so we do not short-change the future needs of the community.
BUDGETING PROCESS
The budgeting process for a large, active school district in California is no simple matter. The Superintendent and staff spend countless hours pouring over programs and needs, factoring in contingencies, and presenting the Board with the best possible budget for the approaching school year, and for the long term year-to-year stability of Bellflower USD. The Board, comprised of five elected representatives reflecting diverse and valuable expertise, reviews the draft budget, provides valued input, and the budget is revised and approved by a committed, intelligent Board every year, with full disclosure of material assumptions, needs and forecasts. It is a collaborative process in our District which has seen exemplary financial stability and continuity as well as expansion of student and community services year after year, and despite the challenges presented that were not of Bellflower USD’s making. While auditors may have a different perspective on budgeting, this process has proven effective to best serve the needs of the Bellflower community other than “on paper” and always with full recognition of the needs and stability of our District.
Finally, it is noted that there were no unethical findings and, as stated in the audit, the District will be working with the Board in formulating action plans for continued improvement.
The following links provide more information regarding reserves and our response to the audit.
https://lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/4216
https://www.auditor.ca.gov/reports/2021-108/index.html#section6
SPECIAL EDUCATION
In the area of special education, Bellflower USD offers a complete range of services for infants through age 22. Bellflower USD has had only a proportionate share of special education complaints. We do our best to make good decisions, but there will be disagreements at times where hearings are necessary. Fifteen hearings between 2017 and 2020, three full school years with 1,700 students receiving special education services, is not an indicator of any problem. We have appealed cases when we believe a bona fide legal dispute existed. One example is requiring the district to pay for a one on one program. That is a highly restrictive educational environment, and federal law requires us to provide the least restrictive environment that allows students to interact with peers. That Bellflower USD does so is to assure that reasonable special education services are appropriately provided while contesting inappropriate or excessive demands.
When we take a case to hearing, a training on the findings is always conducted. Sometimes it is District wide, other times on a smaller as needed scale. We always learn how to better serve our students. We also have several processes for parents who need support with the IEP process. Every site has a Program Administrator assigned to assist in meeting the needs of the students and staff. Parents may contact the special education office with concerns, and a program administrator will contact the parent to work to resolve the concern and may attend IEP meetings as needed to provide support. Additionally, through the Mid-Cities SELPA we have a director who assists parents with concerns and provides parent training. Also, through Mid-Cities SELPA we have Alternative Dispute Resolution vehicles available. While we can always improve, Bellflower USD does an excellent job in fairly and objectively seeking to meet all standards for special education needs.
COLLEGE / CAREER READY
With regard to our students not being prepared for college and career at the same rate as other districts, that is misleading. In order to be considered college career ready, a student must complete the four-year college A-G pathway or take a minimum of a two-year sequence in the same career pathway. Some districts have increased their graduation requirements to meet A-G requirements. Bellflower USD has not, but is investigating this as an option. Bellflower USD encourages and supports students to take the most rigorous pathway to graduation possible. However, Bellflower USD has a high number of students who choose a community college pathway. For those students neither the A-G or a career pathway completion are required, and many opt out in favor of art, music, theatre, or even athletics. Each fall we have over 100 students who enroll in community college through the promise pathway that provides two free years of tuition. Many of these students have not completed the A-G pathway as it is not required for community college admission. This year, approximately 213 students showed interest in the Cerritos Complete program. Our historical success rate at Cerritos College is 82% of our student’s complete college level math and English in their first year, 19% earn an AA or Certificate, and transfer to a four-year university, which is equal to the percentage for all students from districts participating in the Cerritos Complete program, and 12% higher than those students who enroll on their own. Our post-graduation survey shows that of our 829 eligible seniors, 311 plan to attend a community college, 232 will attend a four-year university, for a total of 65.5% of our seniors entering college in the fall, much higher than the state metric reveals.
CONCLUSION
Like any audit, personal or governmental, there may always be things found where further improvement or correction may be recommended despite prior best efforts by Bellflower USD which can and should be acted upon. As the State Auditor offers in its mission statement, the goal is improvement, not criticism for criticism’s sake. After receiving the draft audit report, Bellflower USD’s responses provided context, clarification and further information to assist the State Auditor. Numbers alone do not show the full picture, background and context are also important which Bellflower USD is in a unique position to provide. Bellflower USD remains committed to considering and acting appropriately on all of the State Auditor’s recommendations, but feels at points the audit report fell short in providing a more complete or detailed discussion for the benefit of any reviewing party.
Bellflower USD notes that no failure of internal controls, no wrongdoing, no financial problems were identified by the State Auditor. Where areas of possible improved communications, reporting and transparency are offered, they are and will be accorded respect by the Bellflower USD. While we have disagreements, every one of the State Auditor’s recommendations will be brought back by the Superintendent and her staff to the Governing Board for a full, open discussion, and action plans formulated to continue to challenge ourselves to be better and stronger as a school district. Bellflower USD serves a population of 47,006 with presently 13,806 students enrolled in District schools and programs. It benefits from a Governing Board of five strong individuals for oversight, bringing their skills in such diverse areas of education to Board discussions, and including members with children enrolled in our schools. We have 15 schools under the direction and supervision of the District, with over 1100 staff, teachers and employees coordinated and doing their best for the students and families in Bellflower. Despite the many challenges of the last few years, Bellflower USD is one of the best in fund surplus, conservative budgeting, financial oversight, proactive educational programs, providing a full range of extracurricular programs, and improving performance consistent with the educational needs of our students and input from parents.
There is always room to improve. No one necessarily likes criticism, but when received you don’t run away from it. If merited, you solve the problem. If not warranted, then something is not being communicated which needs to be better or more fully stated. These remain challenging days, and the long hours and hard work put in by everyone at the District explains the achievements to date. Bellflower USD plans to do better year after year. Bellflower USD has reviewed the comments of the State Auditor in looking at the District, and in lieu of simply rejecting or arguing them, embraces the opportunity to learn from them, reassess, and make positive changes so that this valuable exercise serves to improve even further the District’s operations and service to the community.