The 'Cult of Technique' in CPD
How professional learning is becoming lethally mutated
The “Cult of Technique” in teacher professional learning
In the last few years, the professional learning landscape for teachers has become dominated by an obsession with teaching techniques. From full engagement questioning strategies to five step instructional routines, there is an increasing emphasis on what teachers should do rather than what they understand. This phenomenon, which we might call the cult of technique, has translated in schools into a focus on the mechanics of teaching at the expense of deeper pedagogical knowledge rooted in the science of learning.
At first glance, this technique-driven approach appears highly logical and in line with what we know about how deliberate practice improves teacher efficacy. If certain teaching techniques have been shown to improve outcomes, surely training teachers to adopt them will enhance student learning? However, the problem lies in the narrow focus on how to teach without addressing why these techniques are effective in the first place. This narrow focus is often the result of underfunded schools with overburdened senior leaders, desperate for a solution that works.
Teachers are being encouraged to choose from a list of three strategies or techniques and then to simply follow the five-step process. This may not be what was intended either by the toolkit designer or senior leader, but this is the lethal mutation (Browne & Campione, 1996) that such a highly structured and controlled approach becomes when limited by time and money.
Plummeting school budgets have forced headteachers into trying to provide professional learning with limited or no external expert input. INSET sessions and CPD workshops now emphasise a ‘plug-and-play’ model of professional development, using a toolkit of methods and techniques.
Dylan Wiliam famously said in his book, “Creating the Schools Our Children Need (2018):
“Everything works somewhere, nothing works everywhere.”
And it is down to the teacher to make the decision about what will work for their pupils.
The success of a technique depends on teachers being able to make well-informed decisions based on for example, the age of students, prior knowledge, and the broader curriculum, it is not just about being able to follow a five step plan. Without a deep understanding of principles such as the role of the working memory, the difference between learning and performance, or why retrieval practice improves both retention and recall, teachers may implement techniques in ways that are ineffective or even counterproductive.
A common example of the cult of technique is the way retrieval practice has been introduced in many schools. Teachers are often told to start lessons with quizzes, use low-stakes tests regularly, and incorporate spaced repetition into lesson planning. While these strategies align with cognitive science, their value is lost if teachers do not understand why retrieval practice improves memory retention. Without that understanding, teachers may fail to adjust their approach when students struggle, misapply the technique to content that has limited long term value to conceptual understanding, or abandon it altogether when it does not yield immediate results.
This fixation on technique also risks reducing teacher autonomy and professional judgement. If professional learning prioritises the what over the why, teachers may feel pressured to follow prescribed methods without adapting them to their specific classroom needs.
A more effective approach to professional learning starts with building the knowledge of teachers for how learning happens and the key principles that underpin the techniques (EEF, 2021). For example, asking the most effective question is driven by the subject of the question, what you are asking the question about, not just the method, the way in which you ask it. Too often this type of foundational knowledge is missing as schools translate the techniques into their ongoing professional learning programme.
To move beyond the cult of technique, we must recognise that teacher professional learning takes time. Teachers cannot be expected to jump straight into implementation of teaching techniques they do not have the foundational knowledge to support. Empowering educators to think critically, refine their practice and have a lasting impact on pupil progress starts with a commitment to reject the cult of technique in favour of a well sequenced professional learning curriculum that builds the foundational understanding that teachers really need.
References
Brown, A. L., & Campione, J. C. (1996). Psychological theory and the design of innovative learning environments: On procedures, principles, and systems. In L. Schauble & R. Glaser (Eds.), Innovations in learning: New environments for education (pp. 289-325). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Education Endowment Foundation (2021) Effective professional development. Available at: https://educationendowmentfoundation.org.uk/education-evidence/guidance-reports/effective-professional-development (Accessed: 19 March 2025).
Wiliam, D. (2018) Creating the schools our children need: Why what we're doing now won't help much (and what we can do instead). West Palm Beach, FL: Learning Sciences International.
A Little More About Us:
Who are we? - We are Finola & Jane, Literacy & Numeracy specialists, with 45+ years of teaching, training & leadership experience between us.
What's our experience? - We have both worked for Welsh Government supporting schools & senior leaders across Wales. We have held senior leadership posts, delivered support to strategic education advisers, both hold school governor posts and have published curriculum support guidance with Oxford University Press...but if you need to know more visit our website for testimonials from schools we've worked with.
Why should you book our support? - Put simply, because we believe in impact. We do exactly what our name suggests. Our workshop keeps things simple and ensures school actions really work. Our focus is always on delivering measurable impact for pupils
Email: enquiries@impact.wales
Website: www.impact.wales
Phone: 02921 679140
Facebook: facebook.com/impactwales123
Twitter: @ImpactWales
Providing support to schools that has real impact