Without Exception Newsletter
November 2024
🔴 Network OPT-IN 🔴
In order to clean the mailing list and improve deliverability, this opt-in procedure will occur once a year in November. Please respond to David to remain on the mailing list. No response will result in removal from the mailing list. If you are not receiving network emails or you are finding them in your spam folder, then please consider using a different email address. All information is kept confidential.
This notification will also be sent in a separate email.
Network Visibility
Devotion to Christ's heart is essential for our Christian life to the extent that it expresses our openness in faith and adoration to the mystery of the Lord's divine and human love. In this sense, we can once more affirm that the Sacred Heart is a synthesis of the Gospel (Francis, Dilexit Nos, no. 83).
1.25" round metal keychain
3" round vinyl sticker
For LGBTQ+ young persons an affirming symbol can be a lifeline. It communicates "you are precious in my eyes and honored, and I love you" (Isaiah 43:4). The gesture is small, but it increases a young person's sense of value and supports their physical, mental, and spiritual health.
In some places rainbow colors are controversial and beyond the threshold for administrators. That is why the Without Exception logo is designed to be an integrated Catholic symbol. The circle represents the universal (catholic) call to be witnesses to the gospel (1) in all places, “to the ends of the earth” (Acts 1:8); in all times, as symbolized by the colors of the liturgical year; and to all people, as we “look upon our neighbor (without any exception) as another self” (CCC 1931). The heart at the center of the logo is an interpretation of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, and the colors of the liturgical year symbolize glory (gold); Mary and water (blue); blood and fire (red); penance and preparation (purple); life and hope (green); and joy (rose).
The items above are available at cost (including shipping).
- Ten-pack of stickers = $4.00 USD.
- Keychain = $7.00 USD.
- Ten-pack of stickers plus keychain = $10.00 USD.
- NOTE: international shipping will add $2.00-$5.00 USD depending on destination.
I have 500 stickers and 25 keychains. The supply is limited and it is just me doing all of the ordering, handling, and shipping, so thank you for your patience and understanding.
Reflections & Responses
This section is an open forum for members to share reflections or responses connected to our mission.
🚩Please respect the privacy of the authors. These reflections are intended only for the private forum of our network. Public sharing or reprinting is not permitted.
✅ From the Editor
In October, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) released a report that for the first time details the experiences of gender-diverse young persons as captured by the Youth Risk Behavior Survey.
In 2023, 3.3% of U.S. high school students identified as transgender, and 2.2% identified as questioning. Transgender and questioning students experienced a higher prevalence of violence, poor mental health, suicidal thoughts and behaviors, and unstable housing, and a lower prevalence of school connectedness than their cisgender peers. Compared with 8.5% of cisgender male students, 25.3% of transgender students and 26.4% of questioning students skipped school because they felt unsafe. An estimated 40% of transgender and questioning students were bullied at school, and 69% of questioning students and 72% of transgender students experienced persistent feelings of sadness or hopelessness, a marker for experiencing depressive symptoms. Approximately 26% of transgender and questioning students attempted suicide in the past year compared with 5% of cisgender male and 11% of cisgender female students.
The report concludes, "Tools exist to improve the safety and supportiveness of schools, and research demonstrates that when schools make steps to implement inclusive policies and practices, the mental health of all students improves."
For those of us who work in schools, we have a tremendous opportunity to make a difference by creating environments that increase connectedness for all students. The Body of Christ demands as much. As Mother Teresa wrote, "Don't worry about why problems exist in the world, just respond to people's needs."
✅ Fr. William Hart McNichols (Albuquerque, NM)
Be gracious to me, O Lord, for I am in distress;
my eye is wasted with grief, my soul and body also.
Strong as I am, I stumble because of my inequality, and my bones waste away.
I am the scorn of my adversaries, a horror to my neighbors ...
I have passed out of mind like one who is dead;
I have come to be like something lost.
Yes, I hear many whispering - terror on every side -
as they scheme together against me, to take my life.
(A rereading of part of Psalm 31)
As June ends this year, Pride Month too, I am deeply aware of all those, like this Anonymous Priest who came before us, we all “stand on the shoulders of these giants.” They do not deserve to be “like something lost,” as the King David cries in Psalm 31, but to be remembered.
And now the story of this icon, from the book The Men With The Pink Triangle, by Heinz Heger:
“Toward the end of February, 1940, a priest arrived in our block, a man some 60 years of age, tall and with distinguished features. We after discovered that he came from Sudetenland, from an aristocratic German family. He found the torment of the arrival procedure trying, particularly the long wait naked and barefoot outside the block. When his tonsure was discovered after the shower, the SS corporal in charge took up a razor and said, ‘I’ll go to work on this one myself, and extend his tonsure a bit.’ And he shaved the priest’s head with the razor, taking little trouble to avoid cutting his scalp, quite the contrary.
The priest returned to the day-room of our block with his head cut open and blood streaming down. His face was ashen and his eyes stared uncomprehendingly into the distance. He sat down on a bench, folded his hands in his lap and said softly, more to himself than to anyone else: ‘And yet man is good, he is a creature of God!’ I was sitting beside him and said softly but firmly: ‘Not all men; there are also beasts in human form, whom the devil must have made.’
The priest paid no attention to my words, he just prayed silently, merely moving his lips. I was deeply moved, even though I was by then already numbed by the suffering I had seen and indeed experienced myself. But I had always had a great respect for priests, so that his silent prayer, this mute appeal to God, whom he had called upon for help and strength in his bodily pain and mental torment, went straight to my heart.
Our block Capo, however, a repulsive and brutal ‘green,’ must have reported the priest’s praying to the SS, for our block sergeant suddenly burst into the day-room accompanied by a second NCO, seizing the terrified priest from the bench and punching and insulting him. The priest bore the beating and abuse without complaint, and just stared at the two SS men with wide astonished eyes. This must simply have made them angrier, for they now took one of the benches and tied the priest to it. They started to beat him indiscriminately with their sticks, on his stomach and his sexual organs. They seemed to get more and more ecstatic, and gloated: ‘We’ll drive the praying out of you! You bum ...!’ The priest collapsed into unconsciousness, was shaken awake and then fell unconscious again. Finally the two sadists ceased their blows and left the day-room, though not without scornfully calling back to the man they had destroyed: ‘Ok, you randy old rat-bag, you can piss with your ... hole in the future.’ The priest just rattled and groaned. We released him and laid him on his bed. He tried to raise his hand in thanks, but he hadn’t the strength, and his voice gave out when he tried to say ‘thank you.’ He just lay without stirring, his eyes open, each movement contorting his face with pain.
I felt like I was witnessing the Crucifixion of Christ in modern guise. Instead of Roman soldiers, Hitler’s SS thugs, and a bench instead of a Cross. The torment of the Saviour, however, was scarcely greater than that inflicted on one of his representatives nineteen hundred years later here in Sachsenhausen.
The next morning, when we marched to the parade ground, we had almost to carry the priest, who seemed about to collapse again from the pain and weakness. When our block senior reported to the SS sergeant, the later came over to the priest and shouted ‘You filthy ..., you filthy swine, say what you are!’ The priest was supposed to repeat the insults, but no sound came from the lips of the broken man. The SS man angrily fell on him and was about to start beating him once again.
Suddenly the unimaginable happened, something that is still inexplicable to me and that I could only see as a miracle, the finger of God. From the overcast sky, a sudden ray of sunshine illuminated the priest’s face. Out of the thousands of assembled prisoners, only him, and at the very moment when he was going to be beaten again. There was a remarkable silence, and all present stared up fixedly at the sky, astonished by what had happened. The SS sergeant himself looked up at the clouds in wonder for a few seconds, then let his hand raised for beating, sink slowly to his side, and walked wordlessly away to take up his position at the end of his ranks.
The priest bowed his head and murmured with a dying voice: ‘Thank you Lord, I know that my time has come.’
He was still with us for the evening parade. But we no longer needed to carry him, we laid him down at the end of the line with the other dead of the day, so that our numbers should be complete for the roll-call, no matter living or dead.”
But I trust in you, O Lord, I say, ‘You are my God.’
Rescue me from those who persecute me!
I will rejoice and be glad for your unfailing love,
because you have cared for me in my distress
and have not abandoned me
but have set me free.
(Psalm 31)
Fr. Bill McNichols
June 2021
*NOTE: This reflection was shared by Fr. Bill and the image is used with his permission.
✅ Words from Catholic Leaders (Somewhere, USA)
Bishop: "Maybe these kids just don’t belong in our Catholic schools."
Priest: "I've prayed my whole life that I'd never meet a gay person."
Priest (during Sacrament of Penance): "Some things are better left unsaid."
Deacon: "If we can just heal their trauma, then we can help them get better."
Diocesan Chancellor: "All I hear is 'we should keep talking to them, but never do we tell them that their feelings are disordered.' Where is your advocacy for the youth who seek Truth? Who seek witness to Beauty and Goodness found uniquely in the fulfillment of God's will? Who seek refuge from the torrents of a coarsening, sexualized culture in our Catholic schools? Your advocacy for the incredibly small number who are sincerely afflicted with SSA or gender dysphoria, your want for "dialogue," seems altogether disproportionate to our responsibility to reinforce the Natural Law placed on our hearts at conception."
Superintendent of Catholic Schools: "In our schools, our incidence [of LGBTQ+ students] would appear to be much less."
Superintendent of Catholic Schools: "Talking to you would be career suicide."
School Administrator: “We can’t be affiliated with any organization that is affirming of the LGBTQ+ community."
School Staff Member: "You have these kids who are trying to figure out what sex they are? It’s a FAD – that’s what it is, a FAD!"
Youth Minister: "There are no transgender students since no one is transgender."
Youth Minister: "You mentioned to 'Be welcoming to LGBTQ+ faculty and staff,' but while all people deserve to be loved, many should not be hired."
Anonymous: "Toss the troubled kids out. It's unjust to normal children to have to be exposed to this kind of evil nonsense."
* This image was purchased from Naked Pastor for non-profit use *
Featured Artwork
AND JESUS WEPT
(John 11:35).
St. Anthony Shrine, the “Church on Arch Street,” is a center for Roman Catholic ministry in Boston, Massachusetts, directed by the Franciscan friars of the Province of Our Lady of Guadalupe.
Thank You ...
Carl Siciliano
Fr. Kevin O'Neil, CSsR
Dr. Ish Ruiz
Records & Reports
- Please pay special attention to the Readings & Resources section this month. I mentioned in the October newsletter that "Pope Francis and his allies continue to listen and learn." This month there are several reflections written by people who had the opportunity to meet Pope Francis. In his October 24 encyclical, Dilexit Nos, Francis wrote, "I ask our Lord Jesus Christ to grant that his Sacred Heart may continue to pour forth the streams of living water that can heal the hurt we have caused, strengthen our ability to love and serve others, and inspire us to journey together towards a just, solidary, and fraternal world" (no. 220). [Click the picture to see this Sacred Heart icon from Monastery Icons.]
- The Diocese of Fort Wayne - South Bend, IN issued a policy on September 12 to coincide with the beginning of the school year. Additionally, the Archdiocese of San Francisco released an official policy on October 7. This puts us over 60 policies promulgated in the United States. Meanwhile, the Archdiocese of Atlanta recently announced the formation of a new LGBTQ+ Pastoral Affairs Commission, which will be organized under the Restorative Justice Ministry. Presently, I am looking to acquire copies of non-public policies in the dioceses of Dallas, TX and Burlington, VT. Please let me know if you can help locate these policies or others.
- The Association of Catholic Mental Health Ministers is sponsoring a webinar titled "Walking Together: Mental Wellness in Catholic Schools" on Monday, November 4 at 2:00 PM Eastern time. This presentation will explore ways the Catholic mental health accompaniment model can help to enhance the well-being of school-aged children, parents, and school staff. Led by Dr. Michael Boyle, Jen Housel, Mary Permoda, and Dr. Chris Miller -- educators and leaders with firsthand experience in mental health wellness programs and schools, this session will provide practical insights and potential strategies for creating a supportive Catholic School community. Click here for registration.
Readings & Resources
Barnum, Matt and and Laura Kusisto. When Teachers Don’t Want to Use Trans Students’ Pronouns. Wall Street Journal, October 11, 2024.
Barone, Camillo. Transgender Catholics face barriers to religious life, find peace in communities. National Catholic Reporter, October 24, 2024.
Dever, Raymond. Meeting with Pope, Deacon Faults Church for “Stunning Lack of Compassion” to Trans People. New Ways Ministry, Bondings 2.0, October 22, 2024.
Francis. Dilexit Nos [On the Human and Divine Love of the Heart of Jesus Christ]. The Holy See, October 24, 2024.
French, David. Pope Francis is Turning Certainty on Its Head. New York Times, September 19, 2024.
Grimaldi, James. In the room of the synod: A Q&A with Fr. James Martin. National Catholic Reporter, October 11, 2024.
Herrick, Cynthia. Doctor Appeals to Pope Francis: Support Transgender Healthcare, Stop Discrimination. New Ways Ministry, Bondings 2.0, October 24, 2024.
Kuzma, Maxwell. Meeting the pope as my true self: A transgender man's encounter with Pope Francis. National Catholic Reporter, October 26, 2024.
Lemoine, G. James. Embrace, Don’t Avoid, Morally Controversial Topics in Class. Harvard Business Publishing, May 23, 2024.
Martin, James. The (surprisingly positive) change toward L.G.B.T.Q. issues at the synod. America, October 28, 2024.
McKnight, W. Shawn. The keys to a bishop’s role in a synodal church: collaboration and compassion. America, October 15, 2024.
Mental Health America. Crisis Resource Center. Mental Health America, 2024.
Nelson, Andrew. Archbishop Hartmayer forms LGBTQ+ Pastoral Affairs Commission. The Georgia Bulletin, October 18, 2024.
O'Loughlin, Michael. LGBTQ Catholics Share Their Stories at the Synod. Outreach, October 11, 2024.
O'Loughlin, Michael. Outreach hosts LGBTQ Catholic dialogue for Synod delegates in Rome. Outreach, October 9, 2024.
Olson, Kristina, GF Raber, and Natalie Gallagher. Levels of Satisfaction and Regret With Gender-Affirming Medical Care in Adolescence. JAMA Pediatrics, Online, October 21, 2024.
Parker, Kim, Juliana Menasce Horowitz, and Anna Brown. Americans’ Complex Views on Gender Identity and Transgender Issues. Pew Research Center, June 28, 2022.
Santamaria, Nicole. Intersex Catholic Tells Pope Francis a Story of Faith, Violence—And God’s Mercy. New Ways Ministry, Bondings 2.0, October 14, 2024.
Sennett, Michael. In Audience with Pope, Transgender Catholic Says Gender-Affirming Care Is a Blessing. New Ways Ministry, Bondings 2.0, October 19, 2024.
Scott, Katie Collins. Gay music teacher fired by diocese stars in off-Broadway play about his experience. National Catholic Reporter, October 31, 2024.
Shine, Robert. Is It Best for the Synod to Say Nothing At All? New Ways Ministry, Bondings 2.0, October 6, 2024.
Shine, Robert. New Ways Ministry Brings Transgender, Intersex, Ally Catholics for Dialogue with Pope Francis. New Ways Ministry, Bondings 2.0, October 12, 2024.
Suarez, Nicole, et al. Disparities in School Connectedness, Unstable Housing, Experiences of Violence, Mental Health, and Suicidal Thoughts and Behaviors Among Transgender and Cisgender High School Students - Youth Risk Behavior Survey, United States, 2023. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, MMWR Supplement, Vol. 73, No. 4, October 10, 2024.
White, Christopher. LGBTQ issues surface inside and outside Vatican synod. National Catholic Reporter, October 10, 2024.
White, Christopher. Pope opens major Vatican summit pleading for a church where 'each person feels welcomed.' National Catholic Reporter, October 2, 2024.
Winters, Michael Sean. The problems and potential of synodality. National Catholic Reporter, October 30, 2024.
XVI Ordinary General Assembly of the Synod of Bishops. For a Synodal Church: Communion, Participation, Mission. Final Document. The Holy See, October 26, 2024.
Replays & Reminders
- Jory Mertens (ArtByJory) is a Carthage, Missouri-based artist. He works in digital fine art and illustration, often using cubist, geometric, and fauvist elements. Many of his works are based on his view of Jesus as being radically inclusive. He enjoys creating works based on his family, theology, nature, and portraits of heroes of humanity. As a special gift for our community Jory is offering a 30% discount on ALL his artwork with discount code WITHOUTEXCEPTION30. Please do not scan, copy, or otherwise reproduce Jory's artwork. He retains the copyright on all images even after purchase.
- New Ways Ministry announced in August that Bishop John Stowe, OFM Conv., will receive the 2024 Bridge Building Award on November 15. Bishop John was named the Bishop of the Diocese of Lexington, Kentucky, by Pope Francis in 2015 and has been a consistent and strong supporter of LGBTQ+ issues in the US Catholic Church. In addition to leading and participating in numerous LGBTQ+ events, Bishop Stowe supported the Tyler Clementi Foundation statement to protect vulnerable youth and the federal Equality Act, although this act was opposed by the US Conference of Catholic Bishops. He has stood alongside the LGBTQ+ Catholic community by accepting a transgender man as a hermit in his diocese. Whether it has been through his welcoming call for pastoral ministry, his support for civil protections for LGBTQ+ people, or his advocacy for more compassionate responses from the US hierarchy, Bishop John has moved the Catholic conversation on LGBTQ+ issues in a decidedly positive direction. You can read more here.
- Father William Hart McNichols is a friend to our network and is widely known as one of the world’s most gifted living religious artists and iconographers. A former Jesuit and student of the famed Franciscan iconographer Robert Lentz, Fr. Bill’s icons have been honored with exhibitions in major US cities and the subject of a full-length documentary. Recently his years of ministry to the dying during the AIDS crisis in New York City were the focus of a podcast, and later a book, by journalist Michael O’Laughlin. Through interviews with writer and theologian Chris Pramuk, Fr. Bill shares the moving story of his early loneliness and sense of being set apart for some purpose―a purpose realized in his twin vocations as priest and artist. From early childhood, his art expressed his inner life, with special attention to the beauty of the world, the vulnerability of children, and God’s compassionate solidarity with those who suffer. During his AIDS ministry, this took new focus with such works as his “AIDS Crucifixion.” Later, after apprenticeship with iconographer Robert Lentz, he began a new life, producing hundreds of icons of Christ, Mary, the saints, and many holy people of our time. More than a catalog of an artist’s work All My Eyes See is a deep journey into the heart of a great spiritual teacher.
Network Resources
Previous Newsletters
Privacy & Confidentiality
Without Exception is a no-cost ministry network for people in Catholic secondary education and related fields of ministry. The goal is to offer helpful networking and resources to accompany our LGBTQ+ students and colleagues with the love of Jesus Christ and his church. Please respect privacy and confidentiality concerning the persons and schools connected to our network. The strength of this work is sustained by the trust among members.
Mission Statement
Without Exception is a global network of Catholic secondary educators dedicated to discerning the art of accompaniment for LGBTQ+ students in Catholic schools. Through a commitment to faithful dialogue and peer collaboration, we seek to understand what it means to share the love of Jesus Christ with every person, without exception.
Email: info@withoutexception.net
Website: www.withoutexception.net