Play #6: Consequences That Matter
Dr. Q's Classroom Playbook
Is it really a consequence?
For a consequence to work, it must be two things: negatively perceived and considered inconvenient to the student.
Ask 3 Questions
- Does this matter to the student?
- Do I have the authority to give and enforce it?
- Does it make sense for this behavior?
When Possible... Make If Fit, Make It Immediate
Whenever possible, choose a consequence that connects naturally to the misbehavior. If a student misuses a privilege, remove the privilege. If a student creates a mess, have the student clean it up. If a student wastes time, have the student make up that time later, at a time that is inconvenient for the student.
However, not every consequence will logically match the behavior. Sometimes a consequence is simply punitive, and that is okay.
The same is true for timing. Consequences are generally more effective when they can be administered soon after the behavior occurs, but immediate consequences are not always practical or possible.
Match it when you can. Give it immediately when you can.
The Student Decides What Matters
The same consequence will not have the same effect on every student.
Losing a preferred privilege may be a powerful consequence for one student and mean very little to another. Moving a student away from friends may be inconvenient for one student, while another student may actually prefer working alone. In-school suspension may feel serious to one student, while another student may see it as a chance to get out of class.
Pay attention to what matters to the student.
Remember: a consequence must be negatively perceived and inconvenient to the student.
Deliver the Consequence Calmly
Consequences should correct behavior, not communicate anger. Be direct. Be brief. Be calm.
Avoid long lectures, sarcasm, arguing, or embarrassing the student in front of others. State the consequence clearly, explain it only as much as necessary, and move on.
This does not mean every consequence must be given in private. Private conversations can be helpful, but teachers can appropriately give consequences in front of other students when it is practical. The goal is convenience and efficiency, not embarrassment or making an example out of the student.
Students are more likely to accept a consequence when it is delivered respectfully and consistently.
Give the Consequence, Then Move Forward
Since consequences can't always be administered immediately, a student may earn several consequences throughout the day that are tracked and addressed later. What matters is that the teacher follows through, not only by giving the consequence but also by ensuring it is completed.
Once the behavior has been addressed, avoid repeatedly lecturing the student, bringing the incident back up, or continuing to show frustration. Avoid the temptation to "poke the bear."
Address the behavior, follow through with the consequence, and then move forward.
Parent Contact is Communication
Parent contact is an important part of the discipline process, but do not confuse contacting the parent with giving the student a consequence. Parents have the right to be informed, and keeping them informed is an important part of good classroom management.
A parent may choose to give additional consequences at home that the teacher cannot give at school. Those home consequences may be very effective, but teachers cannot always control what happens once the student leaves the classroom.
When appropriate, give the student a classroom consequence you can control rather than relying on the parent to provide the consequence at home. Then communicate the behavior and the consequence to the parent.
Give the student a consequence. Keep the parent informed. Don't confuse the two.
The Goal is Deterrence
The purpose of a consequence is not to get even with a student or make the student suffer. The goal is to make future misbehavior less likely.
A well-chosen consequence creates enough inconvenience that the student pauses the next time and thinks, “Do I really want to make this choice knowing what will happen if I do?”
Consequences should help students make better choices while allowing teachers to maintain positive relationships with them.
Correct the behavior. Deter the behavior from happening again. Protect the relationship.