Standards-Based Grading at Woodland
August 16, 2023

Woodland Introduces Standards-Based Grading and Reporting
Why:
A standards-based approach is more equitable for all students. It allows parents, caretakers, and students to understand more clearly what is expected of students and how to help them be successful in their learning. It measures how well a student understands the material and how they are progressing toward learning goals. (Watch the video in the next story block for more about the "Why".)
How:
Progress is based on a specific set of standards that students need to meet for each grade level. Teachers gather evidence to determine what each student has learned and how that student is progressing toward end-of-year expectations. This approach builds consistent grading practices.
The standards-based approach incorporates equitable grading principles that support three components: accuracy, bias resistance and intrinsic motivation. Woodland has adopted six (6) equitable grading principles that reduce student failure and leverages a positive and trusting learning environment.
When:
Students in Primary, Elementary, and Intermediate Schools will shift from current traditional grading practices to standards-based grading and report cards in the 2023-2024 school year. Middle School students will shift to standards-based grading and report cards in the 2024-2025 school year.
Two-Page Summary for Parents/Guardians
There is a lot of important information related to Standards-Based Grading on Woodland's website. Here is a two-page summary to help you review the highlights!
The Benefits of Standards-Based Grading
There are many benefits to shifting towards standards-based learning:
- Supports current best practices and research.
- Report card grades are based on standards of learning needed at each grade level.
- Students should have multiple opportunities to show evidence of learning.
- Fosters consistency between teachers and grade levels.
- Uses a common language for parents and students.
- Learning habits that support learning are evaluated separately from academic learning.
Grading Periods
Over the next two years, we will implement Trimesters in grades 1-8. Implementing Trimesters means that families will get report cards three times each school year. Trimesters allow additional time for staff to teach, to provide feedback, and to give students opportunities to show what they know through reassessments, if necessary. Review this chart for specific dates.
2023-2024 School Year:
- Primary: Semesters (twice a year)
- Elementary: Trimesters (three times a year)
- Intermediate: Trimesters (three times a year)
- Middle: Quarters (four times a year)
2024-2025 School Year:
- Primary: Semesters (twice a year)
- Elementary: Trimesters (three times a year)
- Intermediate: Trimesters (three times a year)
- Middle: Trimesters (three times a year)
Woodland's Standards-Based Grading Principles
Principle #1: Equitable Grading System
The new standards-based grading will be a 1, 2, 3 and 4 rating system instead of using percentages and points. In a traditional grading system, the implicit inequity of the 100% grading scale provides a larger opportunity for students to fail due to the unequal distribution of percentages. There is a 60% chance of failing and only a 40% chance of passing.
Principle #2: No Averaging Scores
Learning cannot be averaged. Measure students’ mastery of standards by prioritizing the most consistent level of performance and/or most recent performance level rather than averaging all of the grades in a course or unit. A student’s measurement of mastery should not be affected by earlier scores in the unit as students are learning new material and practicing skills. Low scores early in a term that are averaged leave little hope for a passing grade. As a result, students begin to disengage and off-task actions or behaviors may increase.
Principle #3: Separate Academics from Learning Habits
Communicating about learning habits is important and will be reported separately. Scores should only reflect a student’s level of proficiency toward a standard. Combining academic learning and learning habits in the same score is misleading and not reflective of the student's skills. No research supports the idea that low grades prompt students to try harder (Guskey, 2020).
Principle #4: Effective and Constructive Feedback
Feedback will be given to individual students connected to specific learning goals and standards before grades. Specific, actionable, and formative feedback helps students learn and promotes academic growth. Grades are meaningful only when “they are paired with individualized comments that offer guidance and direction for improvement” (Guskey, 2020, p. 216). Feedback “informs the student, the teacher, and all other interested parties about how to best enhance student learning” (Marzano, 2010, p. 3).
Principle #5: Retakes and Redos
Students will be provided with opportunities to retake summative assessments to show mastery of learning standards. All students will learn and have equal opportunities to be successful. Our focus is on finding out what students know and can do. Students will be given additional opportunities, without penalty, to demonstrate their understanding of grade level expectations. Assessments are more than final grades and are used to guide students toward mastery of standard(s).
The most important goal is that students learn the content. Students may need more time to learn standards because they learn at different rates at different times. Research has shown that retakes improve student motivation and interest in school.
Principle #6: No Extra Credit
The practice of awarding “Extra Credit” will not be permitted. Grades are a representation of students’ knowledge of standards rather than the collection of points. Awarding points for outside school activities, learning habits, providing school supplies or other tasks that require time, funds and resources is not equitable for students.
Academics and Learning Habits Reported Separately
Academics and Learning Habits will be reported separately allowing teachers to identify and address specific behaviors that may impact student learning. Learning Habits are aligned with ROAR expectations: Respect, Ownership, Accepting, Ready. Students will be assessed using the same performance ratings such as Exemplary, Meeting, Approaching and Beginning.
Academics and Learning Habits are both equally important to student success, but this must be measured separately. Under this model, student assessments would distinguish between understanding an academic standard (ex: scoring well on an end of unit test), versus having good learning habits (ex: following directions or positively contributing to classroom discussions).
I work for Woodland School District 50 in a communications and public outreach role.