The Center for Teaching & Learning
August 7, 2025
October 6, 2025
Welcome to spooky season! This is the time of year when our thoughts turn to ghosts, goblins, and adjusting our courses to the students we have instead of the students we anticipated back in August. If you’re already digging into the Halloween candy, let me just say that it is totally fine. You deserve it!
I'll spare you all my usual pontification because I hope you'll save your energy and attention for the great articles you’ll find below. We’ve got podcast recommendations, practical approaches to teaching with government sources, articles that follow up on conversations from the CTL session on collaborative assessment practices, and so much more.
Speaking of past CTL workshops, scroll down to the bottom of this newsletter to browse the slides and other materials from sessions you may have missed. And if you haven’t made it to a CTL event yet, it's not too late! From here until the end, we’re having conversations about generative AI and sharing strategies for teaching and research that both lean into the technology and explore low-tech alternatives. If you’d like to join us for these conversations (which always come with food!), RSVP yes using our form.
If you're interested in attending a CTL workshop this fall, please RSVP! This helps us know how much food to purchase, and it helps our facilitators plan a session that best accommodates the size of the group. We'll also send you a calendar invitation so you don't double-book yourself.
If you change your mind later, just take yourself off of the Outlook invitation--no need to update your response to the form.
Teaching happens everywhere at Hood. CTL events are open to full-time faculty, part-time faculty, adjunct faculty, staff, and anyone who is interested in learning and being in community with us.
Thursday, October 9, 1-2 PM
Library 2028
Lunch Provided!
Come spend the hour learning about ways to both include AI in your classroom and AI-proof your assignments. We'll also discuss ways AI can make our lives easier when it comes to the more tedious parts of our jobs, including creating rubrics, question pools for multiple exam versions, and case studies or scenarios. Do you have an assignment where you include AI or one you have AI-proofed? Contact Beth Kiester to be a part of this discussion!
Facilitated by Dr. Beth Kiester, Associate Professor of Sociology.
Wednesday, October 29, 3-4 PM
Library 2028
Candy and other spooky snacks provided.
Suddenly, there’s an AI research assistant for every task, an AI mode for every search platform. What are these tools, and how might they help us in our research? Join CTL and the Beneficial-Hodson Library as we explore the capabilities and limitations of AI in the research sphere.
Co-sponsored by the Beneficial-Hodson Library and facilitated by Emily Belknap (Research & Instruction Librarian), Kathryn Ryberg (Research & Instruction Librarian), and Jessica Hammack (Head of Research & Instruction).
Friday, November 14, 2-4 PM
Library 2028
Crayons, coloring pages, and happy hour fare provided!
This seeds of this workshop were planted on a day when my students and I were burned out, frazzled, and unfocused. I made a spur-of-the-moment choice to bring crayons and coloring pages to class, and we ended up having an amazing discussion as we joyfully brandished our Crayolas! It was a great reminder that while technology can do many helpful things for us, sometimes (especially in the age of “AI”), sometimes we all need to get away from our screens.
In this workshop, we’ll discuss ideas and strategies for low- and no-tech projects, discussions, and in-class activities and share results we've seen in our classes. Whether you're already using low-tech strategies in your own classes or are excited to learn from others who have, JOIN US for a great discussion … and yes, the chance to color your own picture!
Facilitated by Heather Mitchell-Buck, Associate Professor of English.
Integrating Peer Reviews into Classes
Jessica McManus, Associate Professor of Psychology
During this year’s Assesstivus event, I had the chance to talk with some of you about students completing peer reviews of one another’s work. In my Theories of Personality course, students read a scholarly book related to course concepts and then prepare a paper where they highlight five key ideas from the book, connect the book themes to personality theories, and provide suggestions for future research inspired by their reading. To create the peer review sheet, I converted the grading rubric into a series of yes or no questions that guides the peer reviewer’s feedback. As CTL Director, Jessica Hammack, pointed out at Assesstivus, assessments can demystify the grading and assessment process. As students are evaluating their peers’ work, they are also receiving insight into what I am looking for as I grade their assignments and are likely performing a mental evaluation of their own work.
Thanks to my colleagues who joined the discussion and shared their experiences! I compiled a list based on those discussions and present them here as considerations for how you might utilize peer reviews into your classes.
- Reviews could be used for small- and large-scale assignments as well as progressive assignments leading to a larger project.
- Peer reviews could be completed for credit or optional extra credit.
- The peer review guidelines help students know what to evaluate. For example, I am generally more concerned about the content of their work and the quality of their arguments than spelling, grammar, and formatting; the peer review sheets reflect these criteria.
- As noted above, I converted the assignment rubric into “yes” or “no” questions, but continuous ratings may work better for your assignments.
- You may wish to have students work in pairs or with multiple students.
- Students can be paired randomly or based on ability, skills, or knowledge.
- Students can provide reviews anonymously or know who reviewed their work. I take the latter approach and encourage students to have a discussion about their evaluations. A few of our colleagues noted that when students know that their peers will see their work, that peer pressure motivates them to turn in higher quality work.
- Evaluations can take place during class sessions or out of class as an assignment. There is a peer review option on Blackboard Ultra; if anyone has used this function, please share your experience!
- Discuss the importance of peer review and how it impacts professional development with your students. By providing critical feedback to their peers, they are improving this particular assignment while practicing skills they will need for their professional lives.
- Having discussions about the importance of peer reviews and showing students how to provide critical feedback should decrease the number of students who don’t provide helpful feedback to their peers (e.g., those students who say “everything is perfect!”). A graded peer review can also provide a little external motivation for students who might otherwise give overly positive reviews.
The specific ways in which you might use Peer Reviews in your classes might vary but the advantages are clear. The students’ work is often much improved between their initial draft and their completed project. Improvement can be attributed to their peers’ feedback, their own self-reflection, and the fact that they started their paper weeks before the deadline. By having that initial draft ready for peer review, they then have time to make changes, meet with a writing tutor, or talk with me about their assignment. In the semesters where students complete peer reviews, they genuinely seem proud of their work, and that stack of assignments on my desk is more enjoyable to read; it’s a win-win!
Here are some additional resources if you’d like to learn more:
- Student-Led Peer Review: A Practical Guide to Implementation Across Disciplines and Modalities (book by Kimberly A. Lowe et al., 2023)
- Reconstructing Response to Student Writing (book by Dan Melzer, 2023)
- Engaging Ideas: The Professor's Guide to Integrating Writing, Critical Thinking, and Active
- Learning in the Classroom (book by John C. Bean and Dan Melzer, 2021)
- How Peer Review Effectively Supports Student Writing (article by Jason DeHart, 2023)
- Conducting Peer Review (resources from University of Illinois Writer’s Workshop)
- Teaching Students to Evaluate Each Other (resources from Cornell University Center for Teaching Innovation)
- Implementing Peer Review Activities in Your Course (article by Nicole Pizarro, The Ohio State University Teaching and Learning Resource Center)
America 250 or the 250th Anniversary of the United States?
Mary Atwell, Archivist
In January 2023, I attended the local U.S. 250th Planning Summit where approximately 75 people from Frederick, Washington, and Carroll Counties met in downtown Frederick to brainstorm: how would our institutions celebrate 250 years of U. S. independence, as marked by the signing of the Declaration of Independence?
To help state and local institutions across the country, the American Association for State and Local History (AASLH) created a program handbook and guide for programming assistance; the National 250 guidance very clearly stated that funding for state and local efforts would not come from the national level; programming should be from the grassroots up. AASLH created five themes for examining our history: Unfinished Revolutions, Power of Place, We the People, American Experiment, and Doing History – with the encouragement of examining our post-Revolutionary history through the lenses of these themes.
Fast forward to 2025 and things are obviously very different. Viewing America250.org, created in 2021, one can see significant changes. Attorney General of the U. S., Pam Bondi, and Secretary of Defense (or is it War?!) are now on the organization’s board. A huge banner of President Trump, with the America 250 logo and the phrase “American Workers First”, is hung from the Department of Labor building. Finally, a Fox exclusive on Sept. 8 stated that President Trump announced the launch of America Prays, calling on Americans to pray weekly in advance of the 250th birthday. Below is a link to the White House fact sheet.
While some of us may have mixed feelings about the 250th, it is important that we have resources for ourselves and our students so that we can have constructive conversations. As a member of the greater history community, I find the five AASLH themes very helpful. As an example, “We the People” includes the following questions:
How did diverse people experience and influence the events of the American Revolution in different ways?
Who is considered an “American” - and who gets to decide?
How, when, and why have definitions of “the people” and ideas about belonging changed in the U. S., in your state, or in your community?
When and how did different groups of people gain the status of citizenship and what rights and responsibilities did that include?
Who has been, and remains, excluded from full participation and representation in our democracy?
I encourage you to have conversations about the 250th with your students when appropriate, and I recommend the AASLH themes. Below are links I hope you find useful:
Alternative Methods for Grading
Kristen Tzoc, Assistant Professor of Sociology
My semester kicked off with discussions of grading alternatives at the CTL roundtables in August. Since that time, I’ve continued conversations with colleagues (at Hood and beyond), who are using alternatives for grading their courses. In the changing landscape of higher education, there are myriad reasons that faculty consider grading alternatives. Traditional grading fosters competition, reduces students’ development of intrinsic motivation, and often reinforces existing classed, gendered, and racialized social inequalities. It is also a source of anxiety for students and can limit their deep engagement with the course material, as many students become focused on “chasing points” rather than mastering the course content.
In light of these small conversations and much larger shifts in higher education, I want to share a few popular grading alternative methods for anyone who may be interested:
- In the contract grading system, students and their professor negotiate contracted requirements for the course. This can include the weight of assignments within an overall grade or the specific content that students will be assessed on.
- In a guaranteed grade contract system, students who complete the contract-outlined work receive a guaranteed overall grade in the class. Students who fall short of the contract see a reduction in their overall grade, while those who qualitatively exceed the contracted requirements boost their overall grades.
- In a labor-based grade contract system, students are awarded points based on how much time and effort they spend on completing course assignments. Within these systems, faculty may implement multiple opportunities for students to revise and resubmit work or provide students a ‘menu’ of assignment options to complete; the more assignments completed, the higher the grade a student receives.
- In the specs-based grading system, instructors centralize the importance of students meeting specified learning outcomes by providing heavily detailed “specs” for assignments that align directly with these outcomes. Letter grades are determined by the quantity and quality of the “specs” that students meet. Often, students are allowed to revise and resubmit work that fails to meet these “specs.”
- In the ungrading system, traditional points-based grading is eliminated in favor of student self-assessment. Instructors provide detailed, qualitative feedback on assignments for students. Students are also active participants in this assessment through a combination of qualitative peer-reviews, reflections on their overall learning, and self-evaluations of completed assignments.
Scary Is a Matter of Perspective
Kelly Esposito, CTL Graduate Assistant MAH Student
Think back to who you were before you started college. Are you sure you are remembering it all accurately? Can you be sure you haven’t conflated your college experiences with society’s expectations about what the college experience should be? Both psychology and philosophy remind us that our memories might not accurately reflect reality, but how often do we apply this understanding of ourselves in the classroom?
Our own memories of situations help us create a framework for how specific situations should be handled when we experience them again. We advise friends and family when they are experiencing something for the first time, but that advice is based on how we experienced these events ourselves. If you found an activity easy, you will probably tell someone else that they should worry less about their performance (I’m making the leap here in assuming that if you are reading this CTL article you probably had a fairly easy time with your own undergraduate studies). So, it makes sense that you probably advise your students that if they attend class and study they will succeed and that they shouldn’t worry too much. Unfortunately, it is difficult to remember who you were before your mind was significantly altered by your studies. You may be advising freshmen students from a faulty memory of who you were by the end of undergrad or even from an understanding of what the college experience is expected or imagined to be today. Is it possible for us to experience the Mandela Effect on our own college experience memories?
So, what does it matter if you don’t remember your freshman year as well as you should or could? It might matter significantly in your ability to empathize with students. Even the graduate TAs have already forgotten the toll that stress has on undergrad students because to them it’s all old hat now. For new undergrads especially, everything is both amazing but also terrifying and by early October the reality of midterms hits just as the newness of it all is fading. Some students are heading into a bit of a dip that might sound ridiculous to seasoned ears. Student concerns and complaints about college life can start to sound rather insignificant when compared to your own successful but probably highly edited version of your own college experience. We lose empathy when we forget, and no one wants to keep remembering fear.
Thankfully we have the whole (very commercialized) Halloween season to remind us that what is scary is a matter of perspective. That sheet ghost costume is probably terrifying to a four-year-old even if it doesn’t cause you to blink an eye. If you can, take a moment to see the world students see before offering your wisdom this fall. Once upon a time you were probably a terrified freshman and the world looked significantly different to you then, even if you don’t remember it that way now.
Your Academic Podcast Playlist
Nicole Pulichene, Libman Professor of the Humanities
I love academic podcasts. Some are motivating and inspirational, others are cathartic. Below, I review four of my favorites for those looking for new recommendations.
The Academic Imperfectionist
In The Academic Imperfectionist, philosophy professor and academic coach Rebecca Roache offers just the right mix of wisdom, identifiable self-deprecation, and humor while walking herself and listeners back from perfectionist tendencies in academic research, writing, and time management. This is a great place to go when you need a long format meditation on the existential aspects of academic life. Most episodes (including my favorite, #97, “When Failure of Inspiration Strikes”) are scripted monologues delivered in Roache’s reassuring voice, with updates on her 7 rescue cats and barefoot marathons for good measure. Some are interviews with experts on topics ranging from sabbatical planning and writing process to stoicism for modern academics.
Defend, Publish, & Lead
If you’re looking for weekly inspiration and bite-sized, 10-minute tips about academic writing, time management, and productivity, look no further than the Defend, Publish, and Lead Podcast. Writing professor Christine Tully owns the affiliated coaching company of the same name. Rather than selling listeners on paid services, Tully enthusiastically gives out free tips like trick-or-treat candy in every episode. Inspired by Tully’s own commitments in real time, episodes like “Planning for a Teaching-Intensive Fall Semester” and the “Summer Reset” series are well-timed for the ebbs and flows of an academic year. “Grading Time vs. Writing Time” and “Strategies for University Service Requirements” (among others) directly address competing interests in academia while motivating listeners to make time for writing. Also available as YouTube videos, where Tully demonstrates her tips for new software and online resources, the DPL podcast also links listeners to free and low-cost live events as well as supplemental readings in its show notes.
Academic Aunties
Geared to first-generation and racialized academics, Academic Aunties is broadly relevant to minoritized academics as well as their allies. Drawing on her personal connections to women and non-binary professors across Canada and the United States, politics professor and activist Ethel Tungohan does not shy away from heavy topics in contemporary academia: DEI failures, politics in the academy, racist colleagues, student protests, private grief in public life, etc. Each episode feels like an energetic, often hilarious, and sometimes devastating conversation between two or more old friends, in turn offering hope, advice, and even some added fire for self-advocacy and community building on campus.
Academic Life
Academic Life is one of many offerings by the New Books Network. Each episode is an interview with an academic author about their newest book. Host Christina Gessler is a calm constant across the series, posing thoughtful questions and observations that reveal her deep preparedness. At the beginning of each episode, the author describes their academic trajectory and the arc of their research to date. Show notes include curated lists of further reading and listening. In addition to covering a broad range of academic disciplines, Academic Life also features episodes about publishing, grant-writing, and other facets of academia. I couldn’t click quicker on titles like “Finishing your Book when Life is a Disaster” and “Scholarly Skills: Getting from To-Do to Done,” while other episodes gave me leads to course readings.
Missed a CTL event?
Materials from CTL events and workshops are also available as links on the CTL website.
August 12: Assesstivus: Bringing Students in With Collaborative Assessment Practices
This session explored collaborative strategies to include students in the assessment process. We shared numerous classroom strategies such as peer review, co-creating rubrics, collaborative grading, and internship self-evaluations in this ‘speed dating’ -style session.
- Materials available here (requires sign-in).
September 11 & 16: Mixtapes and DIY Galleries: Technology & Techniques for Visual Analysis
Two hands-on workshops about the power of IIIF and Mixtape—a tool for curating and sharing high quality, deep-zoomable, digital visual objects. Thanks to world-renowned institutions—including Harvard, Yale, Princeton, UCLA, Stanford, Oxford, Cambridge, the Smithsonian Museum, and many more—who have opened their collections to the public, you’ll gain the skills to access, remix, showcase, and integrate once exclusive resources into teaching and research.
- Materials available here (requires sign-in).
September 30: From Blackboard to Backpack: Developing a Faculty-Led Study Abroad Experience
This CTL workshop provided a practical overview of how to design and lead a faculty-led study abroad experience: using a study abroad provider or organizing the trip yourself, promoting the trip and recruiting students, navigating risk management, and learning about funding opportunities like the Susan Whaley Study Abroad Development grant and student scholarships.
- Materials available here (requires sign-in).
Faculty Writing Group
Meeting time: Wednesdays at 3-5:30 PM in the Beneficial-Hodson Library (LB 2020)
Coordinators: Beth Kiester (kiester@hood.edu) and Kristen Tzoc (tzoc@hood.edu)
Join the Fall '25 faculty writing group every Wednesday from 3-5:30 pm in Room 2020 of the Beneficial-Hodson Library! We meet weekly to create a shared sense of community, build accountability partnerships, and encourage and motivate one another as we work on our articles, grant proposals, conference applications, syllabi, reviews, and other writing-related tasks. If you'd like to join the group, please email Beth Kiester (kiester@hood.edu) for the Outlook Calendar invite. Snacks provided!
Communities of Practice
Communities of practice are groups of practitioners who share a common interest or knowledge who meet regularly to learn, grow, and build community.
The Tidball Center for Teaching and Learning wants to support your communities of practice, working groups, book discussion groups, teaching observation circles, and more. If you've got an idea that contributes to CTL's mission, then CTL wants to contribute to your idea.
During the times your community of practice meets, you can charge a lunch at the dining hall or snacks from the library cafe to the Center for Teaching and Learning. If you've got an idea, fill out our interest form!
Help us build the Scholarship of Teaching & Learning Research Guide! If you have a resource on teaching and learning, send it to ctl@hood.edu, and we'll add it to the guide.
Join the CTL Zotero Group!
View the CTL Library: https://www.zotero.org/groups/5620207/hood_ctl/library
Help us build the CTL library! Email ctl@hood.edu to be added as a contributor.
Want unlimited access The Chronicle of Higher Education? Access it through the library.
The library also has a section of books dedicated to teaching digitally and physically on the second floor.
- Jessica Hammack, Head of Research and Instruction, CTL Director
- April Boulton, Associate Professor of Biology, Associate Provost, Dean of the Graduate School
- Cathy Breneman, Assistant Professor of Social Work
- Ashley Coen, Assistant Professor of Education
- Sangeeta Gupta, Assistant Professor of Psychology
- Bridget Humphries, Director of Accessibility Services
- Beth Kiester, Associate Professor of Sociology
- Jessica McManus, Associate Professor of Psychology
- Heather Mitchell-Buck, Associate Professor of English, Coordinator of Digital Learning
- Sheila Pierre-Louis, Assistant Professor of Nursing
- Nicole Pulichene, Libman Professor of Humanities
- Adelmar Ramirez, Assistant Professor of Spanish and Latin American Literature
- Kathryn Ryberg, Research & Instruction Librarian
- Kristen Tzoc, Assistant Professor of Sociology
- Jeff Welsh, Director of Instructional Technology in the IT division
- Kelly Esposito, CTL Graduate Assistant
The Tidball Center for Teaching & Learning
Email: ctl@hood.edu
Website: www.hood.edu/ctl
Location: Hood College, 401 Rosemont Avenue, Frederick, MD