BBP Heritage Association
~ April 2026 Newsletter ~
General Membership Meetings
Our April General Membership meeting is open to all and held at the BBP Library. There is also a raffle at every meeting. Please join us for this informative meeting:
Our April meeting will explore the Roosevelt girls. In 1891, John Ellis Roosevelt and his wife Nannie moved their family into their summer estate in Sayville. Daughters Pansy and Gladys were ten and two years old, respectively, and baby Jean was born at Meadow Croft that year. These active, intelligent, and creative girls were active in our local community as well as in the upper-class society of NYC. Join local historian Frank Giebfried as we explore the lives of these fascinating Gilded Age women: their marriages, travels, triumphs, and unfortunate tragedies.
The Roosevelt Girls of Meadow Croft
Frank Giebfried, BBP Historian
Sunday, April 12, 2026
Time: 2:00-4:00
The May meeting, the last one until the fall, will be about the history of the Long Island Railroad.
Dave Morrison, Historian
Sunday, May 17, 2026
Time: 2:00-4:00pm
Dave Morrison, retired LIRR branch manager and railroad historian, will present LIRR history
with a focus on the Montauk Branch. Drawing from 50 years of research, he will cover its 19th
century origins, branches, station history, and share rare photos. Join us for these informative and interesting meetings.
Murder Mystery at Meadow Croft
Back by popular demand! The BBPHA is proud to bring back a Clue-like Murder Mystery event held at Meadow Croft. This will be a repeat performance (with a new twist). Our last performance was a sellout crowd and well received. A fun time was had by all! Put your investigative skills to work as you move from room to room at Meadow Croft and uncover "who did it?" "in what room?" and "with what weapon?"
Save the dates of April 25th and May 9, 2026. Tickets will go on sale through our own website on April 11th. If anyone is interested in volunteering, please reach out to our chairperson Beth at abclamarca@gmail.com. This should be a fun evening for families, friends and detective sleuths! See the flyer below for more information and the preview of the event in "The New York Herald" newspaper article from 1910. Get your tickets early as space is limited.
Help Wanted:
If you are interested in becoming a docent or tour guide for the Meadow Croft estate, please reach out to Jennifer Economos. Tours at the estate are given every weekend from June through October and operate from 2:00-4:00. Training will be available and you can make your own schedule. Interested in local history? Want to learn more? Please reach out to Jen for more information: 631-235-9342.
If you have a group of 10 or more who would like a private tour of the estate, please email us at bbphistorical.com and we would be more than happy to work with you on a date and time.
St Patrick's Day Parade
Thank you to the many friends and neighbors who came out to support the BBP Chamber of Commerce St. Patrick's Day Parade this year. It was a great turnout and very festive!
The Heritage had a wonderful float that was created by Anna Duggan and Jen Economos and marchers included Jerry McCluskey, Leanne Berg, Frank Giebfried and Mary Bailey. Slainte!
Save the dates!
Save the dates, read & share our newsletters, or follow us on Social Media for more information about these upcoming events brought to you by the BBPHA!
April 12, 2026: General Membership mtg at BBP Library 2:00
April 25, 2026: Murder Mystery Night at Meadow Croft
May 9, 2026: Murder Mystery Night at Meadow Croft
May 16, 2026: Historic Bayport & Blue Point Bike Ride
May 31, 2026: First Look Open House at MC for members only (see details below)
June - October 2026: Tours every weekend of Meadow Croft
June 21, 2026: Annual Summer Solstice Walking Tour
June 25, 2026: FREE Summer concert at Bayport Memorial Park
July 11, 2026: Celebration; 250th Anniversary of America!
July 30, 2026: FREE Summer concert at Bayport Memorial Park
August 8, 2026: After Hours at MC; Tavern Night
August 11, 2026: Historic Boat Cruise on the Great South Bay
September 12, 2026: After Hours at MC; Antique Appraisals
December 5-6, 2026: Christmas at Meadow Croft
An A&P You Say???
These stories first appeared in the Bayport Blue Point Gazette and were written by Gene Horton.
They are reprinted here with permission.
March 2014
Historical background: The building in which Cavanaugh's Pub is located today, was built by Blue Pointer, Fred Waldbauer, in 1924 and in November, an A&P food store opened here. Over the years, this building has housed a variety of businesses. In the spring of 1947, another well-known Blue Pointer, Walter A. Mitchell, opened "Walt's Stationary Store" here (pictured below). There was a soda fountain in the store and Walt sold newspapers, magazines and greeting cards. In 1958, Walt sold the store and it eventually became Blue Point Tavern until the building was purchased by the Cavanaughs in 1986.
Anyway, today it's a sports pub. It's an Irish pub. It's a place where everyone knows your name. It's CAVANAUGH'S on Blue Point Ave. in Blue Point! Cavanaugh's is Irish in name and Irish in atmosphere. Flying daily outside the pub are two flags" "Old Glory" (the flag of the USA) and directly underneath it, the green, white and orange tri-color flag of Ireland. It was on St. Patrick's Day, March 17, 1986, that Cavanaugh's Pub officially opened. Chris Cavanaugh is the proprietor. His grandparents hailed from County Clare on the west coast of Ireland. Needless to say, Guinness Stout on tap (not bottled) is one of the most popular "brewed-in-Ireland" beverages served here. On average, Cavanaugh's goes through two or three barrels of Guinness a week.
Another new offering at Cavanaugh's Pub is "Long Ireland" beer and Celtic Ale. And, of course, other classic imports from Ireland include Jameson's, Bushmill's, and Powers Irish Whiskeys. Tullamore Dew ("Give every man his dew"), Bailey's Irish Cream and Irish Mist, are all imported directly from the "ole sod of Erin." Also in Cavanaugh's among all the sport's memorabilia on the walls are 27 television sets! And decorating the walls are beautiful pictures of scenic views of Ireland including the Cliffs of Moher, the Ballybunion Golf Course, two handsome Irish blankets, and, of course, the Irish tri-color hanging from the ceiling in the main dining room at Cavanaugh's.
"We're here for the community," says Chris Cavanaugh. "The community makes Cavanaugh's what it is. Happy St. Patrick's Day and 'Cead Mile Failte' (a hundred thousand welcomes!) to all."