remove_red_eye 3.1K
page background

CfW Research - Progress & Problems

Welsh Govt Publish New Research Report on CfW Implementation

CfW Research -Progress & ProblemsWelsh Govt Publish New Research Report on CfWImplementation

Welsh Government are monitoring the implementation of Curriculum for Wales. They’ve commissioned Arad Research, a group of social researchers & academics to conduct two sets of interviews with sixty-four senior leaders from across schools, special schools and PRUs to understand how CfW is working for practitioners and learners across Wales. The first of the reports informed by these interviews has now been published and you can read it by clicking on the button below.


Now that WG have data on implementation from schools, what is the value of that data and of the issues raised in the report? How should Welsh Government support next steps in schools?


Let’s look first at who has been interviewed as part of the research and when.

Firstly, only volunteers were used. As the researchers say “It is important to acknowledge the risk of selection bias among the sample of schools that engaged with the research. Settings that had progressed further than others in their preparation activities may have been more likely to agree to take part in the interviews.”


Secondly, nearly 50% of secondary schools were ruled out of the research because they had decided to delay implementation of CfW until Sept 2023. We know from Scotland’s experience, that secondary schools have struggled with implementation the most. So, research that fails to take into account the views of those within this sector who have made a conscious choice to delay implementation, cannot be considered representative of the full range of progress in this sector.


Thirdly, there are approximately 1,220 primary schools in Wales. A sample size of twenty-nine, is just 2.4% of the total number of schools. Advice to researchers looking for a representative sample size is to choose a sample where theoretical saturation is reached. That is the point at which you stop learning new things from the views of the participants. Our opinion is that when the research itself highlights that variation in the approach taken is part of the problem, a sample size of just 2.4% has little value in terms of representation.

Fourthly, participants were selected in equal numbers from each of the four regions, even though the geographical spread of schools is not as equal.


Lastly, we need to consider when the interviews were carried out to inform this report. How long had CfW been fully implemented in each school? What opportunity had participants had to experience any potential issues and concerns? How many of them were former pioneer schools, benefitting from additional time and money? Interviews were carried out between November 2022 and January 2023. So that means during the first term of partial implementation. For some, this might have meant a few weeks of implementation had passed before their interview was conducted.


So, what we have in reality is little more than a nice (if expensive) PR project. An opportunity for Welsh Government to present an image of their willingness to listen and understand what’s going on in schools and show that they are responding to the concerns of our school leaders. Unfortunately, this is a well cultivated image of a listening education department, and one that is far from the truth.


Unlike many reports, this research doesn’t provide recommendations, instead they highlight six issues for consideration. Let’s look at each of these issues, why they have been highlighted by the research and whether the suggestions made for addressing them are reasonable.

To read the report click here

Issue One - The Welsh Government should continue to encourage collaboration between settings, focusing on supporting joint-working among Area leads as part of curriculum planning, and evaluation. This should include collaboration between primary and secondary schools.

Collaboration is an issue that comes up repeatedly in participants responses, not as an end in itself, but as a way of managing the level of responsibility and real fear senior leaders have of failing to “get it right.” Again, and again respondents say they and their staff see collaboration as a “reassurance” that what they are doing is right, but also what they are struggling with is what others too are experiencing.


Why is it that schools need so much reassurance? It’s because we are working in a system where schools have been given complete freedom to create their own curriculum, to assess the progress of their learners any way they see fit but will still be held to account through an inspection process which states the aim is for “all pupils make particularly good progress and achieve very high standards”, but with no clear idea of what those standards are. It is not teachers’ perfectionism or sense of integrity that leads them to want to “get it right,” although that plays a part, it is the culture of fear in Wales, fuelled by high stakes accountability. So, whilst collaboration can’t hurt, it won’t solve the problem for schools. During this interim period before publication of the new format GCSEs, WG should take the opportunity to learn from the Finnish system, where terminal examination results are never published by school or used to rank schools but serve purely to inform the inspection & school improvement process. Publication of GCSE results by school should cease.



Issue Two - The Welsh Government should consider whether there is a case for the development of additional resources to support RSE provision, particularly in primary and special schools.

Again, schools need reassurance. In this case, they are struggling with “negative media coverage and fears of parental challenge.” Schools want to make sure that their staff are supported to provide developmentally appropriate RSE education. So, many of them have been buying in commercial packages of resources to take on that responsibility. When budgets are so tight, and the stakes are so high, it seems sensible that Welsh Government would provide a central resource that negates each school having to individually shoulder the burden of accountability of appropriate RSE, when the issue is a national one.


Issue Three - The Welsh Government, working with regional partners, should ensure that international languages are promoted and delivered as an integral part of the new curriculum arrangements in all schools.

We’re not at all surprised primary schools in particular are finding developing international languages alongside the additional demands of Welsh and English difficult at the moment. Post multiple lockdowns, pupils’ language development in their native language has taken a hit, but even more so Welsh where it is not the first language at home. This is a clear sign that schools cannot do it everything all at once. They need time. Time and money. Unfortunately, both are currently at a premium. Maybe the minister should be looking at what is already working well and put his full support and further resources behind the Welsh Sentence Builders project as a first step to creating a nation of multilingual people?


Issue Four - During the second wave of research with senior leaders as part of this study, there should be a focus on understanding the learning points at school level from the trialling of new progression models, including how schools have refined and improved their approaches.

Issue Five - The Welsh Government should continue to monitor the potential implications of divergence in settings’ and clusters’ approaches to monitoring progression, particularly in considering how to monitor progress at a national level.

Let’s take these two issues together because they are at the heart what of this whole curriculum reform process is about. The progress of children in Wales. To know if Curriculum for Wales has been a success, we need a way to be able to measure pupils’ progress across the whole of Wales. That means directly comparing the progress pupils make in one school with another, one local school curriculum with another, one approach to pedagogy to another. Direct comparison is only possible using common measurement tools. Which is why the diversity in ways in which schools are measuring their pupils’ progress appears in two of the five issues. We know that WG are currently developing sampled standardised testing of a range of skills across the curriculum. We also know that our inspectorate is already making judgements about whether pupils are reaching high standards. However, if every school is measuring that progress in a different way, the accuracy of our inspectorate’s judgements are on very shaky ground.


The problem here is the curriculum model, not schools’ approach. CfW has variation baked into it. There are no standards in CfW. The Descriptions of Learning are narrative descriptors, which in some cases are broad, highly subjective statements that are difficult to interpret, impossible to measure. Teachers and schools have the freedom to design the curriculum their children need but continue to be held to account by the publication of legacy GCSE results. Progress in learning is extraordinarily complex. It is not easily reducible to a number or a grade, something that can be put into a spreadsheet and crunched to create a graph of whole school progress. The most forward-thinking schools are moving towards a two-level approach to monitoring assessment, using a lean, focused collation of progress data against what has been taught, coupled with a small range of nationally standardised tests to check that pupils’ standards are in line with the rest of the nation.


Issue Six - Senior leaders frequently referred to a desire for reassurance that the approaches they are taking to curriculum planning, progression and, particularly, assessment were appropriate (and ‘on the right track’). While collaborative working between schools goes some way to providing reassurance, Welsh Government should consider whether there is a need for a role that provides external constructive challenge to schools (particularly around progression and assessment) during these early years of implementation.

This final issue says it all. The profession is asking for reassurance that what they are doing is right, because they are operating in a culture of fear and accountability. It strikes us that providing more external challenge will just lead to more fear, a greater need for reassurance, not less. Schools need clarity and certainty, not more accountability and challenge.


What this report tells us is that the issues we’ve known about in CfW for some time, of variation between schools leading to problems with equity and schools’ ability to effectively tackle disadvantage, remain. It also tells us that the researchers and academics involved in this research weren’t able, or possibly willing to dig down to the underlying issues at the root of the senior leaders’ concerns. Preferring rather, to focus on surface issues such as collaboration and spread of international languages. We are left thinking that Welsh Government are very busy listening to the challenges the profession is experiencing with making Curriculum for Wales work, without managing to really hear anything of what is being said.

zoom_out_map

A Little More About Us

Who are we? - We are Finola & Jane, Literacy & Numeracy specialists, with 35+ years of teaching, training & leadership experience between us.


What's our experience? - We have both worked for Welsh Government supporting schools & senior leaders across Wales. We have held senior leadership posts, delivered support to strategic education advisers, both hold school governor posts and have published curriculum support guidance with Oxford University Press...but if you need to know more visit our website for testimonials from schools we've worked with.


Why should you book our support? - Put simply, because we believe in impact. We do exactly what our name suggests. Our workshop keeps things simple and ensures school actions really work. Our focus is always on delivering measurable impact for pupils

Email: enquiries@impact.wales
Website: www.impact.wales
Location: Caerphilly, UK
Phone: 029 2167 9140
Facebook: facebook.com/impactwales123
Twitter: @ImpactWales

Loading indicator

close