The Center for Teaching & Learning
August 7, 2025
April 2026
I’ve always found April to be a time of chaos and contradiction. On the calendar, it’s a time of renewal and fresh starts: baby animals, flowers blooming, and starting seeds for my garden. When it comes to the academic calendar, we are frantically helping students finish both semester-long and year-long projects. It’s a time filled with SPIRES presentations, honors projects, and year-end reports. It’s no wonder we are all exhausted! In this newsletter, you will find information focused both on wrapping up the spring semester while also looking ahead to the not-so-distant fall semester. Enjoy!
First, I want to send out the heartiest of thanks to Kelly Esposito, CTL GA extraordinaire! She will be leaving Hood after this spring semester to rejoin her partner in California and finish her Master of Arts thesis remotely. She has been such a guiding light as I have made the transition to the director role, helping me to learn about the processes and tasks the position has historically been responsible for, teaching me about producing this newsletter, and being instrumental in setting up all our workshop events. I will truly miss her next year! Now, if you happen to know of any returning graduate students that might be up to the task of filling her shoes, please send them my way. The official job posting should be out very soon!
Next, I want to draw attention to our last workshop for the year focusing on Accessibility and Technology in the classroom. It’s a happy hour event this Friday, April 17 from 2-4pm in Lib2028 with pizza and a variety of beverages available for this discussion. You can also stop by for some cake and to wish Kelly well in her next adventures.
Now, on to the fall. Thank you so much to everyone who has already filled out our needs assessment survey ! This will be used as the CTL advisory board meets to start planning events for 2026-2027. If you haven’t done so, please take just two minutes to give us your suggestions.
Finally, you will find two new sections that will be ongoing throughout the next year. The first section, “Rethinking Thinking: Higher Education and AI,” will be a space for sharing anything and everything that has to do with higher education and AI. Topics may include the role of Liberal Arts colleges in the AI era, ways to AI-proof assignments, ideas for incorporating AI meaningfully into the classroom, ethical dilemmas, and tips that might improve your own workflow. Shared items can include podcasts, webinars, articles, best practices, survey data, and most importantly, examples from our own colleagues as they grapple with this technology that is running rampant in every corner of the world. I invite everyone to share any materials they come across so that we can build a repository of information that will be constantly changing.
The second section, “Access Granted: Making Course Materials Work for Everyone,” will be used to develop another repository of materials geared towards digital accessibility and compliance with new DOJ 2024 updates to Title II. I provide further information below. Regardless of the new mandate, making course materials accessible for all learners is an important component of making all students feel welcome in our classrooms. I’ve already included a webinar on this topic, From Checklists to Check-ins: Accessibility, AI, and Human Judgement in EdTech, that I found to be so insightful and addresses both Title II mandates and where AI can be helpful and where it misses the mark in these tasks. And of course, it’s the topic for our last workshop of the year!
I’ve enjoyed my first semester in this role, and I look forward to an exciting new year ahead!
Signing off until September,
Beth
Upcoming Events
Access or Advantage? Assistive Technology in the College Classroom
Pizza and Booze Happy Hour
Friday, April 17, 2-4 pm, Lib 2028
Facilitated by Drs. Heather Mitchell-Buck and Bridget Humphries
AI is here. Is it always cheating, or is it sometimes an accessibility tool? Join us for pizza, adult beverages, and a practical conversation about academic integrity, assistive technology, and what we’re really assessing in our classrooms. We’ll start with some short case studies and discuss practical changes we can each make in our instructional practices. We invite you to bring a course assessment with you to workshop in a small group— either one that you feel works well or one that you would like help improving, or both!
2026 Faculty OER Mini-Grant Call for Proposals is open!
The Maryland Open Source Textbook (M.O.S.T.) Faculty OER Mini-Grant Program support faculty efforts to increase access, affordability, and achievement for students at Maryland's postsecondary institutions through the incorporation of open educational resources (OER) into teaching practice.
The goals of the M.O.S.T. Faculty OER Mini-Grant Program are to impact student success through:
-
- OER use in teaching high enrollment courses (Adopt/Adapt OER grants)
- OER creation/revision and publication in high-need areas (Create/Revise and Publish OER grants)
- New! OER revision for digital accessibility (DA Revision OER grants)
Visit the M.O.S.T. Faculty OER Mini-Grant Program to learn more and access the call. Proposals are due by 11:59 pm ET on Friday, April 17, 2026. Questions may be directed to most@usmd.edu
A big thanks to Emily Belknap for sharing this amazing opportunity for external funding!
Embedding the COMPARE Framework in Collaborative Grading Practices
Sangeeta Gupta, Assistant Professor of Psychology
I recently came back from a conference where a lot of our conversations kept coming back to the limits of instructor-feedback on student learning. After one of these chats, I dove into some work from Trinity College, Dublin, on comparison-based approaches to learning, where students are asked to evaluate their own work against rubrics, exemplars, or peer examples and then articulate what needs to change (COMPARE Framework; Fellenz, Brady & MacMahon, 2021). The emphasis is not on increasing instructor feedback, but on building students’ capacity to generate and use feedback internally.
This made me reflect on my own classroom practices. In my research methods classes, I already use a collaborative grading model that includes co-designing rubrics, self-assessment, and revise-and-resubmit cycles. Students are given published papers and accepted conference posters as examples, and they work together to define what counts as strong performance. They then apply those criteria to their own work, reflect on their progress, and revise accordingly. I have written about this approach in more detail in The Power of Collaborative Grading (CTL Newsletter, January 2025). But despite my best efforts, I felt that students did not consistently engage in the evaluative process or apply the criteria independently in the way I envisioned.
While learning more about the COMPARE Framework, I saw one key step that was missing from my classroom implementation: a structured stage in which students systematically compare multiple examples, apply the rubric across them, and justify their judgments in relation to a shared standard. I typically only offer them examples of high-quality work, such as successful SPIRE posters, published manuscripts, and approved IRB proposals as reference points.
In practice, these examples function primarily as benchmarks students can look to while developing and applying their own work. What is missing is the requirement for students to actively evaluate multiple examples against one another using the rubric, articulate why one example demonstrates stronger alignment with specific criteria than another, and defend those judgments. Without this explicit comparison and justification process, students may benefit from exposure to high-quality work, but they are not consistently pushed to test and refine their own interpretations of the criteria through direct, structured evaluation across examples.
Collaborative grading is already doing much of the work of making expectations transparent, engaging students in evaluation, and making revision a key part of learning. My next step is not to replace this model, but to integrate structured comparison into it. Strengthening this step helps move students from using rubrics as guides for grading to using them as tools for alignment and independent learning. For further reading, I highly recommend Trinity College’s COMPARE framework linked below.
Fellenz, M., Brady, M., & MacMahon, M. (2021, June). A guide to deploying comparison activities to support student learning. Trinity College Dublin; National Forum for the Enhancement of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education. https://compare-trinity.weebly.com/uploads/9/0/5/4/90545695/tcd_compare_doc_v3.1
Student Evaluations and What to do with the Comments
Catherine Breneman, Assistant Professor of Social Work
As the academic year wraps up, students will be asked to evaluate faculty teaching when they are at one of the most pressured times in the semester, the final weeks of class and the days before final exams. Some faculty click on the link for evaluations as soon as the email is received. Others wait for time to pass in order to distance from the course and the students. Still others, avoid until there is no option but to review the feedback. I read an interesting article called, “Student Ratings of Instruction: What about Those Written Comments?” by Melissa J. Himelein. In the article, she talks about the differences between quality feedback and the open-ended narrative responses that we receive from student evaluations. Sometimes, the overall evaluation is good, but we still get hung up on one negative comment. Here are some of her suggestions (copied directly from the article):
1. Calculate participation rates. Students who complete the quantitative ratings section of evaluations may or may not opt to provide written feedback, which can result in low response rates. In four studies conducted in the past decade, the percentage of students who answered one or more open-ended questions ranged from 39 to 67 percent. Consider a course of 30 students: If 55 percent complete the overall course evaluation (a typical rate at U.S. universities), and 60 percent of those provide written comments, just 10 students (one-third) are now representing the entire class. Before reading any of the comments, count the number of responses for each item, divide by the total number of students in the class, and write the corresponding percentage next to each question. Keep this participation rate in mind to maintain some perspective as you dive into the prose.
2. Organize responses by student or by other relevant variables. Most course evaluation summaries present the written comments by item rather than by student. While helpful for spotting trends, this format prevents instructors from discerning, for example, whether a highly critical response to four different items comes from one disgruntled student or four different students. You may also choose to organize written comments by variables assessed in the numerical items that are potentially associated with overall evaluation trends, such as majors vs. non-majors, expected grade, perceived workload, or how much time students report devoting to the course.
3. Solicit an unbiased review. Qualitative researchers note the importance of “perspective management” in data interpretation, with investigators urged to recognize and minimize their own biases. Try giving written comments to a trusted colleague; when written comments aren’t about one’s own teaching, it’s easier to look at them objectively. Or share comments with professionals in your campus’s faculty development center. Having encountered a broad sample of written comments over time, they can help you place yours in context.
4. Perform a content analysis. Another option, also borrowed from qualitative research (which is, after all, what we are doing when reading written comments), is to perform a systematic evaluation of the responses using the procedures of a standard qualitative analysis. Focus on representative rather than unique comments, and try to identify themes or categorize around standard areas of teaching emphasis (e.g., organization, feedback, accessibility). Combine written comments across several courses and semesters for a richer and more representative pool of data.
5. Consider tossing the outliers. Why not delete, or at least ignore, the non-representative responses, a common practice in quantitative research analyses? In a 2011 article in Quality Assurance in Education, Wongsurawat offers an interesting strategy. Assess every comment for its reliability and representativeness, based on correlations between the individual comment and the class averages. Similar to the outcome of item analyses performed in test construction, responses that do not correlate can be discarded. Not all comments merit scrutiny.
6. Add your own questions. There’s an argument that open-ended items explicitly directing students to identify faculty weaknesses or strategies for improvement encourage negative feedback that would not be elicited with broader prompts. In any case, you can probably do better. What do you want to know, and what would actually help you to improve? Most course evaluation forms permit adding supplementary questions.
7. Instruct your students in the art of giving feedback. Providing written comments can be a teachable moment. Talk with students about the type of responses that are helpful and that motivate teachers to make changes. In a study published in 2014 in Higher Education, Tucker found that when students were explicitly instructed in how to provide constructive, professional feedback, the rate of abusive or unprofessional comments was less than 1 percent.
Himelein, M. J. (2017, September 9). Student ratings of instruction: What about those written comments? Academic Leader.
How to Renew Enthusiasm and Engage Students
Kelly Esposito, CTL Graduate Assistant MAH Student
It has been a grand adventure working as the CTL GA for the past two years and I am thankful for every minute of it!
What have I learned? I have learned that as soon as I think I know enough about any topic then it’s time to hit the books again. And when the books fail to provide me with more information then there are people and experiences that can offer me a new take on the same old thing. Whenever I think I have done it all, well, it’s time to approach the same topic from yet a different angle. Personally, when all else fails to stimulate a new way of thinking, then it’s time to touch grass.
Sure, everyone knows we need to drink water and touch grass when we get stressed! But even if you don’t think that you are stuck or stressed may I suggest going out and touching some grass anyway? If you teach in any capacity at Hood, the best place to touch grass is on the quad. The quad can offer you a way to renew your excitement for teaching in a way that touching grass anywhere else in the world can’t. The quad offers a chance to see Hood students in the wild. Carefree or stressed. Slowly wandering or rushing to class. In silent contemplation or screaming like, well, like a college student! Seeing students out of the classroom allows you to see them anew both as individuals and as a group, where it becomes clear that they are just people like yourself who have also come to explore the world in a new way.
If hanging out in the quad isn’t your thing, consider attending a couple CTL events to learn novel ways to help your students engage with your favorite topics. Get them as excited as you are about your subject! (Are you still excited about your topic?) Sure, it’s a challenge if they are disinterested, but it is a greater challenge to engage students if you are disinterested. So, renew yourself with a little time on an Adirondack chair while contemplating where your interests and your students’ interests overlap. It could open up new ideas for you to share in the classroom and beyond. As an added benefit, your renewed enthusiasm will likely be enough to win over even the most indifferent lecture attendees. Teaching students how to become excited by something that doesn’t immediately interest them and how to explore these new ideas without fear or judgement from as many different angles as possible is the ultimate goal.
Rethinking Thinking: Higher Education and AI
Spring 2026 Generative AI Virtual Showcase is a workshop that will take place on Friday, April 24, 2026, from 9am-3pm with limited-enrollment, virtual pre-conference workshops taking place on Thursday, April 23, 2026. Free for faculty and staff from accredited Maryland higher education institutions.
The Showcase will follow three tracks:
Track 1: Philosophical and Critical Conversations in AI
This track focuses on AI tensions and debates, ethics, and academic integrity. Proposals might address approaches to teaching responsible AI use, developing institutional or course-level AI policies, navigating plagiarism and attribution concerns, exploring ethical dimensions of AI in society and education, or engaging students in critical examination of AI’s societal impact.
Track 2: Engaging Students with AI
This track emphasizes student-centered AI integration for learning and skill development. Proposals might address students using AI tools as collaborators in the learning process (brainstorming, drafting, revision, tutoring, feedback), assignments that help students understand how AI works and evaluate AI outputs, or activities that invite students to critically examine AI’s role in their discipline and future profession.
Track 3: AI for Course Design, Accessibility, and Faculty Productivity
This track highlights faculty and staff use of AI to enhance teaching effectiveness and efficiency. Proposals might address using AI to create greater transparency and relevance in course materials, enhance accessibility for diverse learners, create or adapt open educational resources (OER), improve inclusive teaching practices, streamline feedback workflows, or support course redesign efforts.
Heads we win, tails you lose: AI detectors in education is an article that evaluates AI detection tools and cautions against their reliability due to biases. The increasing use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) in student assessment has led to institutional reliance on detection tools. Unlike plagiarism detection, AI detection relies on unverifiable probabilistic estimates. In this paper, we argue that generative AI detection should not be used in education due to its methodological imperfections, violation of procedural fairness, and unverifiable outputs. Generative AI detectors cannot be tested in real-world conditions where the true origin of a text is unknown. Attempts to validate results through linguistic markers, multiple tools, or comparisons with past work introduce confirmation bias rather than independent verification. Moreover, categorizing text as human- or AI-generated imposes a false dichotomy that ignores work created with, not by, AI. Generative AI detection also raises security concerns. Academic integrity investigations must rely on evidence meeting the balance of probabilities standard, which generative AI detection scores do not satisfy.
From Checklists to Check-ins: Accessibility, AI, and Human Judgement in EdTech is recording of a webinar on the relationship between generative AI and accessibility. It is especially helpful for thinking about the requirement shifts of Title II discussed in more detail below. Accessibility works best with intentionality. What makes it meaningful is what makes it human: reflection, judgment, and care. At the same time, AI-driven tools are transforming EdTech faster than ever — offering real opportunity to streamline accessibility at scale, while raising important questions about how institutions maintain ethical decision-making as technology becomes more central to learning design.
Access Granted: Making Course Materials Work for Everyone
Understanding Title II, the DOJ 2024 Ruling, and what it means for Hood College
The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA) is a Federal law that provides civil rights protections to individuals with disabilities similar to those provided to individuals on the basis of race, color, sex, national origin, age, and religion. The ADA has five sections or “titles” which each address different areas of the law. Title II protects qualified individuals with disabilities from discrimination on the basis of disability in accessing services, programs, or activities. Requirements of Title II include equality in participation and benefits (i.e., Persons with disabilities must have an equally effective opportunity to participate in or benefit from institutional programs, services, and activities) and reasonable modifications (i.e., The institution must reasonably modify its policies, practices, or procedures to ensure access and equal opportunity to individuals with disabilities).
On April 24, 2024, the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division (DOJ) issued a final rule revising Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The rule requires state and local governments to make their websites and mobile applications accessible for people with disabilities. The agency is adopting the technical standards of Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA, which requires 50 success criteria to make websites accessible. This includes converting pictures and documents so they can be read with assistive technology for individuals with vision loss and providing captions for live and prerecorded videos for individuals with hearing loss. In their fact sheet, DOJ has also listed exceptions to this rule, including archived content that is not currently used, pre-existing conventional electronic documents, content posted by third parties under certain circumstances, individualized documents that are password-protected; and pre-existing social media posts. Organizations with less than 50,000 persons have three years, until April 24, 2027, to become compliant with these updated standards.
What this all means is that over the next academic year, Hood College will be tasked with making sure we are compliant with this ruling. As chair of the Academic Technology Group, Marisel Torres-Crespo was selected to lead a Title II Implementation Working Group. This group will:
- Review the ADA Title II Final Rule and its applicability to higher education
- Establish a realistic and actionable implementation timeline
- Identify responsibilities across departments, including intersections with Title IX and other compliance areas
- Explore free tools and resources that help assess accessibility and track compliance
- Develop a checklist to ensure we are consistently meeting required standards
As CTL Director, I will be soliciting and providing resources for faculty to make sure any of their digital materials are also compliant. Example tasks may include making sure videos have closed-captioning and/or transcriptions, pictures have alt-text (pro-tip: I love using AI to generate alt-text for images), and making sure course documents are screen-reader friendly. There will be much more to come in the fall, but if you have any favorite resources for digital accessibility, it's never too early to send them my way. I highly recommend the webinar posted above in Rethinking Thinking: Higher Education and AI.
Faculty Writing Group
Meeting time: Wednesdays at 3-5:30 PM in the Beneficial-Hodson Library (LB 2020)
Coordinators: Beth Kiester (kiester@hood.edu) and Kristen Tzoc (tzoc@hood.edu)
Join the faculty writing group every Wednesday from 3-5:30 pm in Room 2020 of the Beneficial-Hodson Library! We meet weekly to create a shared sense of community, build accountability partnerships, and encourage and motivate one another as we work on our articles, grant proposals, conference applications, syllabi, reviews, and other writing-related tasks. If you'd like to join the group, feel free to drop by or email Beth Kiester (kiester@hood.edu) for the Outlook Calendar invite. Snacks provided!
Missed a CTL event?
Materials from CTL events and workshops are also available as links on the CTL website.
August 12: Assesstivus: Bringing Students in With Collaborative Assessment Practices
This session explored collaborative strategies to include students in the assessment process. We shared numerous classroom strategies such as peer review, co-creating rubrics, collaborative grading, and internship self-evaluations in this ‘speed dating’ -style session.
- Materials available here (requires sign-in).
September 11 & 16: Mixtapes and DIY Galleries: Technology & Techniques for Visual Analysis
Two hands-on workshops about the power of IIIF and Mixtape—a tool for curating and sharing high quality, deep-zoomable, digital visual objects. Thanks to world-renowned institutions—including Harvard, Yale, Princeton, UCLA, Stanford, Oxford, Cambridge, the Smithsonian Museum, and many more—who have opened their collections to the public, you’ll gain the skills to access, remix, showcase, and integrate once exclusive resources into teaching and research.
- Materials available here (requires sign-in).
September 30: From Blackboard to Backpack: Developing a Faculty-Led Study Abroad Experience
This CTL workshop provided a practical overview of how to design and lead a faculty-led study abroad experience: using a study abroad provider or organizing the trip yourself, promoting the trip and recruiting students, navigating risk management, and learning about funding opportunities like the Susan Whaley Study Abroad Development grant and student scholarships.
- Materials available here (requires sign-in).
October 9: Ctrl+Alt+Teach: Rebooting Education with Generative AI: Beth Kiesster
In this workshop, we discussed practical ways to both discuss AI in the classroom and AI-proof assignments.
- Materials available here (requires sign-in).
October 29: Nothing to Be Afraid Of: AI Research Tools for Literature Reviews and More
In this workshop, we explored the capabilities and limitations of AI research tools, specifically NotebookLM, LitMaps, and Consensus.
- Materials available here (requires sign-in).
November 14: Color Your Classes: Low- and No-Tech Projects for You and Your Students
In this workshop, we discussed ideas and strategies for low- and no-tech projects, discussions, and in-class activities.
- Article from Heather Mitchell-Buck available here.
February 3: Reframing Microagressions to Create More Inclusion and Better Learning Outcomes
In this workshop, Dr Michael Baran, author of The Subtle Acts of Exclusion, presented his his work on microaggressions, inclusion, exclusion, and belonging.
- Slides from Dr Michael Baran available here.
February 24: Gamifying the Classroom
Dr. Mahesh Joshi presented on the need for and the efficacy of gamifying the classroom. He covered the advantages of gamification in the classroom, and of course, we played a game!
- Slides from Dr Mahesh Joshi available here.
March 19: Scaffolding for Student Success
"What is academic scaffolding and how can you add it to your courses?" Clarity and small signs of support can make a huge difference for students and give them the confidence they need to thrive in your classroom. Facilitated by Kelly Esposito, GA for The Tidball Center for Teaching and Learning
- Slides from Kelly Esposito available here.
April 2: From Potential Ally to Effective Ally: When Inclusion Intentions Produce Subtle Acts of Exclusion
This workshop drew on Subtle Acts of Exclusion (Baran & Jana, 2020) to examine two central questions: How can an ally, whose goal is inclusion, inadvertently create exclusion? and What happens when intention doesn’t converge with impact? The session distinguished between the potential ally, who reacts quickly and defends intention, and the effective ally, who pauses, centers impact and prioritizes repair. Extending Baran and Jana’s (2020) framework, participants left with practical strategies to redistribute power and strengthen trust, credibility, and belonging in and out of the classroom. Facilitated by Dr. Akeem Todman
- Slides from Dr Akeem Todman available here.
Communities of Practice
Communities of practice are groups of practitioners who share a common interest or knowledge who meet regularly to learn, grow, and build community.
The Tidball Center for Teaching and Learning wants to support your communities of practice, working groups, book discussion groups, teaching observation circles, and more. If you've got an idea that contributes to CTL's mission, then CTL wants to contribute to your idea.
During the times your community of practice meets, you can charge a lunch at the dining hall or snacks from the library cafe to the Center for Teaching and Learning. If you've got an idea, fill out our interest form!
Want unlimited access The Chronicle of Higher Education? Access it through the library.
The library also has a section of books dedicated to teaching digitally and physically on the second floor.
- Beth Kiester, Associate Professor of Sociology, CTL Director
- April Boulton, Associate Professor of Biology, Associate Provost, Dean of the Graduate School
- Cathy Breneman, Assistant Professor of Social Work
- Ashley Coen, Assistant Professor of Education
- Sangeeta Gupta, Assistant Professor of Psychology
- Bridget Humphries, Director of Accessibility Services
- Jessica McManus, Associate Professor of Psychology
- Heather Mitchell-Buck, Associate Professor of English, Coordinator of Digital Learning
- Sheila Pierre-Louis, Assistant Professor of Nursing
- Nicole Pulichene, Libman Professor of Humanities
- Adelmar Ramirez, Assistant Professor of Spanish and Latin American Literature
- Kathryn Ryberg, Research & Instruction Librarian
- Akeem Todman, Director of Inclusive Excellence
- Kristen Tzoc, Assistant Professor of Sociology
- Jeff Welsh, Director of Instructional Technology in the IT division
- Kelly Esposito, CTL Graduate Assistant
The Tidball Center for Teaching & Learning
Email: ctl@hood.edu
Website: www.hood.edu/ctl
Location: Hood College, 401 Rosemont Avenue, Frederick, MD