The A(I) Standard
Issue 2: March 16 ,2026
How Harris v. Hingham Proves Modeling AI Works
Let’s be honest: the rapid rise of AI in schools has felt a bit like being told to fly a plane while we’re still building the cockpit. We want our students to be future-ready, but we also want to keep academic integrity intact.
However, there is a new "legal reality" every teacher needs to know about. It’s called Harris v. Hingham (2024), and it changes the game for how we handle AI "cheating" accusations.
The "Fair Notice" Rule
In this recent case, a student challenged a disciplinary action for using AI, arguing the school handbook was too vague. The court ultimately upheld the school's discipline, but for a very specific reason: the teacher had provided a lesson and a written handout explicitly outlining AI expectations at the start of the year.
The court’s takeaway for us is clear: Your specific classroom instructions are your strongest legal defense. In the eyes of the law (and RIDE), an AI detector score is just a data point—it isn't a "smoking gun." We need "Due Process," and that starts with the clarity you provide. We strongly encourage you to use the tools in our AI Teacher Tool Kit, which contains a tip sheet on the steps to report suspected cheating, and contains the AI Acceptable Use Scale you can hand out prior to a lesson.
Modeling: Your Shield, Not Just a Strategy
To support you in this, all staff will soon be required to participate in District AI Literacy Training. This training is designed to move us from "detecting" to "directing," ensuring your assignments are "audit-proof" by focusing on the Three Pillars of Due Process:
Clear Frameworks: Don't just say "No AI." Tell them, "For this essay, you can use AI to brainstorm a thesis, but the actual drafting must happen in class or within your shared Google Doc."
Explicit Modeling: If you allow AI for research, spend five minutes showing them what an "ethical" prompt looks like versus one that bypasses the learning objective.
Process Evidence: Shift the focus from the final product to the process. If a student can explain their work in a restorative conference, that is far better evidence than any AI detector score.
The Bottom Line
We aren't asking you to be AI experts overnight. We are asking you to be transparent. When you model how AI should (or shouldn't) be used for a specific lesson, you are creating a "Fair Notice" environment that protects you, the district, and the students.
Our upcoming training will provide you with the tools to implement these practices efficiently, ensuring complete alignment with state and federal regulations as well as RIDE and U.S. Department of Labor guidelines.
If you want to learn more about the case, you can read it here
Let’s lead with human clarity, not just software.
POLL: What AI Topic are you most interested in?
What AI topic do you want to know more about?
Process Over Product: Assessing Learning in the Age of AI
If an AI Can Grade It, the Lesson Might Be Broken
With AI, when a stack of essays comes your way for grading, you might now be thinking: “How much of this is actually the student’s voice?” It’s a frustrating, exhausting way to teach.
For years, we’ve relied on the "Final Product" as the ultimate proof of learning. But in 2026, we have to face a hard truth: The final product is no longer a reliable metric. If a prompt is simple enough for an AI to generate a passing response, it is simple enough for an AI to grade it—and that means the learning objective has officially been "automated" out of the equation.
The Reality Check
AI isn't a fad that we can out-wait or out-detect. The industry is moving faster than any detection software can keep up with. If we spend our nights running papers through "AI checkers" (which, legally and technically, are increasingly unreliable), we are playing a game of whack-a-mole that we are destined to lose.
The Shift: From Product to Process
So, how do we move forward? We have to change the way we design assignments. We need to move the "evidence of learning" from the final paper back into the classroom. Consider this: If a student can’t explain the how and the why behind their work, they didn't do the work. To stay ahead of the curve, we are encouraging a shift toward "Process-Based Assessment." This isn't about more work for you; it's about better evidence from them. Think about integrating these shifts:
Establish a "No-AI" Baseline: At the very start of the year, have students complete a significant writing or problem-solving task in-class, with pen and paper, and no tech allowed. Ask them to sign a "No-AI Pledge" for this specific task. This serves as your "Baseline Sample" of their authentic voice, making it much easier to spot anomalies in later assignments.
The "Verbal Defense": A quick, 2-minute "Socratic" check-in where a student explains their thesis. AI can write a paper, but it can’t look you in the eye and defend a logic leap.
In-Class Scaffolding: Moving the "heavy lifting" of drafting into the classroom. If the outline and the first draft happen in front of you (or in a Google Doc with a visible version history), the final product becomes a formality, not a mystery.
Authentic Application: Assigning tasks that require local, real-time context. AI is great at generalities, but it struggles with what happened in our cafeteria yesterday or our town council meeting last week.
The Bottom Line
We can’t stop the tide, but we can change how we swim. When we design lessons that prioritize human insight, critical reflection, and live interaction, we make cheating nearly impossible—not by using a detector, but by making the "shortcut" useless.
Don't feel like you have to figure this out alone. If you're struggling to modernize a legacy assignment, ask the AI for help. You can use tools like Gemini or ChatGPT as a "Pedagogical Partner."
Try a prompt like this: "I have a traditional essay assignment on [Topic]. How can I rewrite the rubric to focus 60% of the grade on the 'process' (drafting, reflections, and verbal defense) and only 40% on the final paper?"
Let's shift our perspective. We can be proud of the prize (the final paper), but the real magic is the effort. The teamwork, the plan, and the struggle—the process—is what makes the success worth it. Let's focus on the learning that happens in the room, because that is the one thing an algorithm can never replicate.
AI Prompting Playground
Palindrome Game
Prompt: "Create a palindrome game. You give the first and last letter of 10 palindromes, along with a definition that helps us guess what the word is. Create it for a grade 5 class."
The "Lesson Breaker"
Prompt: "Act as a brutally honest veteran teacher and curriculum auditor with 20 years of experience in [Insert Grade Level, e.g., 5th Grade]. I am going to provide a lesson plan, and I want you to tear it apart. > Do not be polite. Look for the following 'Breaks':
The Boredom Gap: Where will students lose interest or start doodling?
The Logic Leap: Where is the instruction too vague or the jump in difficulty too high for this age?
The Timing Trap: Which part will actually take 30 minutes even though I only gave it 10?
The 'So What?' Factor: Is the 'hook' actually engaging, or is it just 'teacher-talk'?
After you find the weaknesses, give me three 'Fix-It' bullets to make the lesson bulletproof. Here is the lesson: [Paste Lesson Here]"
"Ants Eye View" Story Prompt
Prompt: "I want you to act as a tiny, friendly garden ant named Pip. Write a short story (about 200–300 words) for a 2nd-grade classroom (7–8 years old).
The story should include:
Sensory Details: What does the grass look like when it’s taller than a skyscraper?
Science Facts: Mention how you use your antennae to 'smell' and how you follow an invisible scent trail left by your sisters.
Teamwork: Describe finding a large snack (like a dropped cracker crumb) and calling for help.
Tone: Adventurous, brave, and helpful.
Formatting: Use short sentences and simple vocabulary. Use a clear 'Beginning, Middle, and End' structure."
Did a robot write this? Video by EdTech Teacher Eric Curts on AI Cheating
This video is about an hour long and contains some great insight. It's an optional item, but worth the time.