remove_red_eye 3K
page background

New Made for Wales Science GCSE

No-one is happy with Qualifications Wales' decision

New Made forWales Science GCSENo-one is happy with Qualifications Wales' decision

Why the learned societies don't support the Made for Wales Science GCSE

Last week Qualifications Wales published their decision on what the new Made for Wales GCSEs will look like. Since then, there has been much discussion and concern about those Science GCSEs.


Let’s first consider the current situation in terms of standards in science education in Wales.

In the last set of PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) tests set by the OECD in 2018, Wales' score in the science was category lower than those of the other three UK nations, and slightly below the OECD average.

Although Wales’ science score of 488 represented a slight increase on the previous set of test results, it was significantly lower than the first time Wales entered Pisa in 2006, when it got a score of 505.

What’s more, the next set of PISA tests, to be sat in 2025, will have a focus on science.

This is the backdrop against which decisions about science GCSE qualifications have been made. Currently we have a multi-tier system where pupils can choose from a wide range of GCSEs:


  • GCSE Science – a double award GCSE which combines elements of all three sciences
  • GCSE Applied Science – double or single award
  • GCSE Physics
  • GCSE Biology
  • GCSE Chemistry


Pupils can do a single award, combined science, or a separate GCSE in Physics, or a double award combined science. The new single and double award combined science GCSE seems to be significantly limiting the choice for pupils, especially at the upper end of attainment.

The learned societies in Wales want to see a single route at GCSE science. A single combined qualification where pupils have the option to study in all three of the sciences. They want this for the sake of equity. All pupils studying the same range of sciences. They thought Qualifications Wales would deliver only a double award, combined science GCSE.


What teachers want is a system of GCSE science study that adequately prepares all pupils for whatever their next step on their learning journey is. Whether that is the world or work, or to study science at A Level and university. Teachers also want this for the sake of equity. All pupils having the option to study science at an appropriate level.


In a Q & A session on Twitter last night, Jeremy Miles, Minister for Education, responded to teacher concerns that removing the option to sit 3 separate science GCSEs was a “dumbing down” & would leave a wider knowledge gap between GCSE & A Level, saying “experts…are confident the new double award will enable learners to progress successfully to science AS and A levels. Learned bodies in biology, physics and chemistry have supported this too.”

However, this support from the learned societies for the double award GCSE, was only provided on the understanding that the double award would be the only science GCSE available. The Institute of Physics now says; “We are unable to support the proposals if they are a two-tier offering.” The other learned societies are of a very similar view, with the Royal Society of Biology saying “RSB has significant concerns that the decision to introduce a new single award GCSE in The Sciences, without consultation, undermines the positive reforms in the new double award GCSE.”


It’s also difficult to square the changes to the science GCSEs with the Welsh Government’s own ambitions when it comes to science in Curriculum for Wales.


The introduction to the Science and Technology AoLE (Area of Learning and Experience) in the Curriculum for Wales guidance states: “The importance of science and technology in our modern world cannot be overstated. Developments in these areas have always been drivers of change in society, underpinning innovation and impacting on everyone’s lives economically, culturally and environmentally. As such, the Science and Technology Area of Learning and Experience will be increasingly relevant in the opportunities young people encounter and the life choices that they make.”


If science is to become “increasingly relevant” in young people’s lives, why are their opportunities for study in this area now being limited?


The Made for Wales GCSE Science qualifications have created two new problems, an inequitable two-tier system AND one that disadvantages our most able scientists. It seems that Qualification Wales believes that the number of pupils getting a qualification, any qualification in science is more important than the number of scientists who enter and graduate from university.


We wonder what standards in science education in Wales will look like in ten years’ time?


Click the links below to read the learned societies' responses to the science GCSE decision from Qualifications Wales.

The Association for Science Education response
Institute of Physics response
Royal Society of Biology response
Royal Society of Chemistry response
zoom_out_map

A Little More About Us

Who are we? - We are Finola & Jane, Literacy & Numeracy specialists, with 35+ years of teaching, training & leadership experience between us.


What's our experience? - We have both worked for Welsh Government supporting schools & senior leaders across Wales. We have held senior leadership posts, delivered support to strategic education advisers, both hold school governor posts and have published curriculum support guidance with Oxford University Press...but if you need to know more visit our website for testimonials from schools we've worked with.


Why should you book our support? - Put simply, because we believe in impact. We do exactly what our name suggests. Our workshop keeps things simple and ensures school actions really work. Our focus is always on delivering measurable impact for pupils

Email: enquiries@impact.wales
Website: www.impact.wales
Location: Caerphilly, UK
Phone: 029 2167 9140
Facebook: facebook.com/impactwales123
Twitter: @ImpactWales

Loading indicator

close