The Cognitive Demands of Learning
How managing competing cognitive demands improves learning
Every time we teach, it's a balancing act between these 3 cognitive demands
One of the three key principles of meaningful learning, is that our cognitive capacity is limited. This limitation can cause significant issues not only for the learner, but more importantly for teachers considering how to design lessons that result in meaningful learning.
A research paper from Richard.E.Mayer published in 2023, explores the competing cognitive demands that are always present for the learner. He also sets out how teachers can use these cues to create better, more effective lessons. Mayer outlines three cognitive demands that are competing for that same limited processing capacity. They are:
- Extraneous processing - this is the cognitive load created by how the new material is presented to the learner. Whether this is in a textbook, on a PowerPoint presentation or verbally by the teacher. If the new material is presented in a way that increases cognitive load, by including inessential information, or by the teacher talking whilst pupils are reading a detailed and long paragraph of different text on a slide, or by splitting pupils' attention between information in their books, in a textbook and on a screen, this can make things much harder for the pupils.
- Essential processing - the amount of cognitive capacity required to represent the new material in the learner's working memory. This is dependent on the complexity of the material being presented. So, for example, being asked to multiply two, single digit numbers together has a lower complexity and cognitive load than being asked to multiply fractions together. The more complex the concept or learning, the greater the load for the learner.
- Generative processing - this is cognitive processing that is aimed at making sense of the incoming information. This type of processing depends on the learner's motivation to do something with the learning. That might be to draw a picture of their learning, or to rework a text into a flowchart or labelled diagram, or to summarise a large body of information into a single short sentence.
Knowing that these three cognitive demands are competing for the same processing capacity, helps us to see how to improve our lesson design and instructional methods to ensure pupils' learning experiences are as meaningful as possible.
If we look at the three diagrams in the sketchnote above, we see three different scenarios, where a different cognitive process has been allowed to dominate the pupils' capacity.
In the first picture on the left, we have high extraneous processing. Pupils are being asked to read a long paragraph from a presentation, whilst simultaneously listening to instructions from the teacher. This is highly ineffective and pupils are unlikely to be able to grasp the new content. Getting rid of redundant information from the presentation, including labelled visuals and allowing pupils to take in the slide for themselves, before the teacher adds additional information verbally are all ways of reducing the extraneous processing load.
In the second picture in the middle, the extraneous load has now been reduced through a simplified presentation but now we have a highly complex concept that is being presented and the load created is just too much for pupils' cognitive capacity. They have little to no capacity remaining to make sense of the concept for themselves and the learning is not retained well. A simple way to manage this scenario is to chunk a more difficult and complex concept into small bite sized sections, so that the cognitive demand for the learner is reduced.
In the final picture on the right, extraneous load has been minimised by a simplified presentation, a complex concept has been chunked into more manageable pieces, so there is plenty of cognitive capacity for the pupil to assimilate the learning, to make it their own and understand it deeply by doing something with the learning themselves. However, they are not motivated to do so on their own. This is where using generative tasks can prompt the pupil to increase their generative processing. The kinds of tasks that could be used include asking pupils to write a summary of a longer piece of information, getting them to draw an illustration of their understanding, sorting or ranking content or even explaining their understanding to a peer.
Having an understanding of key principles of cognitive science enables teachers to design more effective, higher impact lessons for all pupils. If you'd like to find out more about the in-person or remote professional learning that we provide as workshops or as bespoke professional learning packages for schools contact us:
- enquiries@impact.wales
- 029 2167 9140
Download a free copy of the complete sketchnote by clicking the button above. You can also read the original research paper by Mayer (2023) by clicking the link below.
A Little More About Us:
Who are we? - We are Finola & Jane, Literacy & Numeracy specialists, with 45+ years of teaching, training & leadership experience between us.
What's our experience? - We have both worked for Welsh Government supporting schools & senior leaders across Wales. We have held senior leadership posts, delivered support to strategic education advisers, both hold school governor posts and have published curriculum support guidance with Oxford University Press...but if you need to know more visit our website for testimonials from schools we've worked with.
Why should you book our support? - Put simply, because we believe in impact. We do exactly what our name suggests. Our workshops and professional learning packages keep things simple and ensures school actions really work. Our focus is always on delivering measurable impact on pupils' learning.
Email: enquiries@impact.wales
Website: www.impact.wales
Phone: 02921 679140
Facebook: facebook.com/impactwales123
Twitter: @ImpactWales
Providing support to schools that has real impact