remove_red_eye 706

Bulletin Board

Bulletin Board
BulletinBoard

City Schools of Decatur Board of Education City Schools of Decatur Board of Education

The City Schools of Decatur BOE meeting recap newsletter is shared after each regularly scheduled monthly meeting. The January Board of Education meeting was held on January 14, 2025.


Meeting Agendas:

Pre-Work Session

Work Session

Regular Meeting


The recording, which includes the pre-work session, work session, regular meeting, and public comment, is available here.

Board Members Board Members

Board Members

Dr. Carmen Sulton, Chair

Mr. Hans Utz, Vice Chair

Mr. James Herndon, Board Member

Mrs. Jana Johnson-Davis, Board Member

Ms. Tracey Anderson, Board Member

Ms. Sophia D'Elena, Student Board Representative

Election of Board Officers Election of Board Officers

The board unanimously elected Dr. Carmen Sulton as the 2025 Board Chair and Mr. Hans Utz as the Vice Chair.

Student and Staff Recognition Student and Staff Recognition

Decatur High School All-State Football Specialist

Congratulations to Evan Fisher on being selected as an All-State Specialist (Punter) for his exceptional performance on the football field. Being named an All-State Punter means that Evan is one of the top punters in the entire state—an impressive achievement that reflects his skill, consistency, and impact on the game.


His achievement is even more remarkable because Evan has only played football for two years. His dedication, hard work, and relentless pursuit of improvement, combined with the guidance and support of his coaches, have made him the only punter in all of 5A to earn this distinction.


Evan is a standout athlete and a great student at Decatur High School, embodying the true meaning of being a Decatur Bulldog—hardworking, driven, and proud of his school and community. He has made our team, school, and community incredibly proud. Most of all, Evan has made his family proud, and we are honored to recognize him tonight.

Falcon Friends at Fifth Avenue Upper Elementary (F.AVE)

Tonight, we are highlighting Falcon Friends at F.AVE, started this year by Ms. Edwin Ellis, a LINKS teacher at Fifth Avenue.


Ms. Ellis has proudly worked at F.AVE for 10 years, and during this time, she observed countless positive interactions between administrators, teachers, custodians and students. Without hesitation, the adults at F.AVE come to the aid of students who might have fallen on the playground, had a tough morning, needed some motivation to make it through the day, or needed help resolving a conflict.


After seeing this so often, Ms. Ellis thought, why not make it official? She and her team launched Falcon Friends at FAVE. This mentorship program fosters positive relationships between school staff members and students. School mentors volunteer their time during the school day to meet with their assigned mentees. Mentors receive weekly guidance with detailed discussion topics to use during mentee meet-ups. They focus on topics like communication, making and maintaining friendships, and accountability for ourselves and our actions. We are so excited about the response to this program. F.AVE mentors and mentees have reported positive responses to the program.


We have some of the program's student mentees here tonight; please join us up front as I read excerpts from your experiences.


  • Everett Kreitel, 3rd grade, says: I like Falcon Friends because if you have anxiety, this is perfect to help solve it. If you are ever having a bad day, you can ask to be pulled out. For me and maybe others, that helps the day might be better.

  • Clark Cain, 5th grade: One thing that I love the most about Falcon Friends is that I get to play games with my mentor, Dr. McKenzie.

Chair's Comments Chair's Comments

Good evening. On behalf of the City Schools of Decatur Board of Education, I wish everyone a Happy New Year and thank you for joining us in person and virtually to learn about the progress of our strategic goals.


I thank my fellow board members for electing me to chair this distinguished governing body. I must also thank Board Member James Herndon for his leadership over the past two years. I look forward to working with each board member, Superintendent Dr. Whitaker, the administration, and the CSD students, staff, and families to achieve positive academic and social-emotional outcomes for all students.


This evening's meeting is our first board meeting of the new year. During the pre-work session, we participated in an annual assessment using the GSBA Governance Team Assessment based on the Georgia State Board of Education Standards for Effective Governance. While it is not intended as an evaluation instrument, this tool provides the board and superintendent with a status review on implementing identified best governance practices.


Additionally, there was continued discussion from the December meeting on protocol regarding staff political activities, along with a review of an initial draft of policies related to general public relations, including possession of weapons by visitors.


The board heard two presentations during the work session. During the first one, the board and public received an update from the newly named safety and technology services division. As the board continues to work towards ensuring competitive compensation for staff, the second presentation provided concepts for next school year's salaries. The board accepted three policies on drug-free workplaces, staff's responsibility to report criminal activity, and public participation in board meetings for the first read. An update to the regulation on public participation in board meetings was also shared.


The presentations for all board meetings are available on the district's website in Simbli.

Every month, the board looks forward to celebrating our schools and the achievements of our students and staff. At tonight's meeting, we recognized an All-State athlete from Decatur High School and the dedicated members of a staff-initiated mentorship program at Fifth Avenue Upper Elementary. January is National Mentoring Month, so this recognition is very timely. We congratulate our student and staff for their achievements.


Now that the second semester is underway, I encourage our families and the community to continue to support our students and schools. Check school newsletters through the CSD Weekly for upcoming events and activities.


As I conclude my remarks, I have a few dates that I want to bring to the public's attention.

This month, CSD will follow the legal procedures for opting out of House Bill 581, establishing a statewide floating homestead exemption and cap on property taxes. Three public hearings were previously publicized. The first was virtual this morning. The second, an in-person/hybrid hearing, will follow tonight's board meeting. The third public hearing will be virtual on the evening of January 21 at 6:45 p.m. Two additional virtual hearings have been added and publicized for January 30 at 10 a.m. and 6:45 p.m.


Please mark your calendars for the next Board of Education Community Meeting on January 22 at 6:45 p.m. at Glennwood Elementary School. The agenda will include a discussion on the Georgia Vision Project, an update on Early Learning, FY26 Budget Development and community Q&A.


On January 30, I will present on behalf of CSD at the annual State of the City.

Finally, the next board board meeting will be Tuesday, February 11, 2025.


That concludes my remarks for this evening.

Superintendent's Comments Superintendent's Comments

Note: The presentation slides shown during the Superintendent's Comments are available here.


Happy New Year, City Schools of Decatur! I trust everyone had a safe semester break and made the most of the recent snowfall.


I usually begin with the month's observances. However, this month, I want to highlight and personally invite everyone to a few events hosted within CSD.


CSD will host the annual MLK/CSK Awards this Thursday, January 16, from 6 p.m. - 7:30 p.m. at Fifth Avenue Elementary School. In addition to coinciding with the observance of the national MLK holiday, this event honors grades 3-12 recipients of the Dr. Martin Luther King Jr and Coretta Scott King Awards for demonstrating leadership and service to the community that embodies the principles and ideals of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr and Mrs. Coretta Scott King. The guest speaker will be Decatur State Representative Omari Crawford.


The tragic events over the past year, including two in school districts, prompted requests from families to learn more about what CSD is doing to ensure the safety of our students and staff. In response, CSD will host a School Safety & Security Summit on January 27 at 5:30 p.m. at the Decatur High School PAC. The summit will highlight the district's enhancements to safety and emergency readiness. Our emergency management partners from the City of Decatur Fire and Police departments will join us. Please join us for this critical conversation. Also, please register using the link on the district's website.


The third event is for information. Members of the Board of Education and I will be visiting the Grand Rapids Community College Early Learning Laboratory in February to inform the planning, design and programming of our new early childhood learning center.


Opening Slide

Equitable Outcomes for All Students Does Not Equal Disproportionality

While planning to expand our early learning strategy is a long-range strategy to achieving equitable outcomes for all students, I must clarify what we are required to do now.


The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) requires states to make annual determinations of districts identified as having disproportionality. On January 26, 2024, the state notified the City Schools of Decatur of our FY24 Disproportionality Determination. The Georgia Department of Education reviews policies, procedures, and practices for all districts identified as having a disproportionality determination. During FY24, the City Schools of Decatur received a disproportionality compliance review and were found compliant.


However, due to having seven (7) or more years of Significant Disproportionality, the City Schools of Decatur received an onsite visit by the Georgia Department of Education (GaDOE) October 30-31st this school year that included interviews, observations, review of lesson plans and surveys. Out of 181 school districts, you may wonder how many the state is providing targeting assistance due to their designation. So, how did we get here…


Slide 2 - CSD Strategic Plan: All In Decatur


The City Schools of Decatur Board of Education adopted a 5-year strategic plan in March 2023 called "All in Decatur." Each presentation made by staff includes the alignment to the pillars of the strategic plan known as strategic accelerators. The accelerators are captured on the back of the strategic plan. Last year, we refined some of the initiatives beneath the accelerators and gave the document a facelift, but one thing we did not do was change the first page. The first page is the foundation.


There were five things this Board and the community wanted everyone to know about this plan.


  1. Recenter the school district's focus on students. My question when first reading was, what are we focused on if not students?

  2. Weave equity into the fabric of everything we do. Not just discipline and curriculum, but funding.

  3. Reimagine what school looks like to meet the needs of ALL students.

  4. Create a space where every student feels included.

  5. A strategic plan that incorporated feedback from all stakeholders throughout Decatur.


These five things remain unchanged and undergird the strategic plan.


Slide 3 - Superintendent Entry Plan and Objectives


Also, in March of 2023, the Board of Education announced me as the sole finalist for superintendent. Walking into the district, I was asked to look into three things instructionally: how we teach reading, how we provide interventions, and how we could close the achievement gap between black students and their peers. First, I want to say this Board was spot on! The instructional leadership, beginning with the superintendent but moving through the newly established instructional cabinet to principals, must all know how to address those instructional challenges. As we build the capacity to address the concerns organizationally, we must communicate them effectively. I saw that challenge very early on. To be specific, September 13, 2023.


Slide 4 - Student Support Structures - All Means All


As I addressed the administrative staff, I shared we are not a Disney World. We cannot "fast pass" to an IEP. I was in the Gathering phase of GEM, my entry plan. I attended a few IEP meetings and reviewed our data. And we were doing precisely that, skipping the intervention process. Once again, this Board was spot on! Not only did I see we were identifying black students at a higher rate and disciplining them at a higher rate, but so did the Georgia Department of Education.


Slide 5 - State Oversight: Definition of Significant Disproportionality in Georgia


A school district is significantly disproportionate when students identify, place outside the regular classroom, or discipline children from any racial or ethnic group at a markedly higher rate than their peers. The mathematical equation is noted on this slide. But essentially, the risk ratio means the student in the racial or ethnic group is 3 times more likely to be identified, placed, or disciplined for 3 years or more. In addition to the designation, a fiscal requirement on average of $150,000 for Check & Connect, LexiaCore5, and a Student Engagement Coach that would otherwise go to special education. This requirement is called Comprehensive Coordinated Early Intervening Services (CCEIS). The Georgia Department of Education annually approves these services.


Slide 6 - State Oversight: CSD Specific Area of Disproportionality


For City Schools of Decatur, the FY24 Disproportionality is for the identification of black students in the area of specific learning disability. Specific learning disability is defined as a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, that may manifest itself in an imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell or do mathematical calculations. The term includes such conditions as perceptual disabilities, brain injury, minimal brain dysfunction, dyslexia and developmental aphasia.


The child with a specific learning disability has one or more serious academic deficiencies and does not achieve adequate according to age to meet State-approved grade-level standards. These achievement deficiencies must be directly related to a pervasive processing deficit and to the child's response to scientific, research-based interventions. The nature of the deficit(s) is such that classroom performance is not correctable without specialized techniques that are fundamentally different from those provided by general education teachers, basic remedial/tutorial approaches, or other compensatory programs.


This is clearly documented by the child's response to instruction as demonstrated by a review of the progress monitoring available in general education and Student Support Team (SST) intervention plans as supported by work samples and classroom observations. The child's need for academic support alone is insufficient for eligibility and does not override the other established requirements for determining eligibility.


Now, I know I just said a lot. But remember what the Board said: I needed to look into how we teach reading, interventions, and achievement gaps.


Slide 7 - State Oversight: Identification Data & Resources


When the state shared the data, it was from our FTE counts, specifically the special education enrollment by race and ethnicity, beginning at age 3 and continuing through early childhood education through 21. The state rules that we may be in violation of are child find, the process I just explained, evaluation and reevaluation timelines and the assessments and processes we use to determine eligibility. To determine us disproportionate, the data is reviewed annually, but what brings you to the level of State oversight is 7 or more years.


Slide 8 - State Oversight: CSD Historical Data Overview


Dr. Jana Johnson-Davis was a teacher in the district when we first flagged for dispro for discipline and was a part of the committee that addressed it. Disproportionality goes back to 2017. The part of this slide that breaks my heart the most is we began to be disproportionate in identifying black students after the pandemic. After not being in school for almost two years, something is quote-unquote wrong with the black student. If we know our black student demographic data in Decatur, the black student is more likely economically disadvantaged as well and did not have access to tutors before, during or after the pandemic. So, when we are asked why we are always talking about student data, tests, and discipline, and why is that always a part of the board meeting at the sub-group level, this is why.


Slide 9 - School-Based Support for Equitable Outcomes


Where are we now in the process - GADOE has conducted the site visit, and we are awaiting their feedback and expect to have ongoing targeted support. Having been in multiple school districts where GADOE provides targeted support, I can attest that it will look and feel different to the staff. I have shared this with them, and it will be different. This is not someone else's problem. It is our problem. We must look at this work as evidence of the inequity of MTSS, child-find, evaluations and determinations. Additional positions will be added to the K-5 level (2 and K-2 and 1 at 3-5) - not the district at the Wilson Center level 3 - to address this inequity at the school level.


Slide 10 - New Equitable Outcomes Role in Schools


These roles will report to the principal, but let me be clear. These positions will be filled with individuals who are knowledgeable and courageous enough to facilitate crucial conversations with school-based staff to ensure that all instructional and behavioral strategies are inclusive and responsive to the needs of diverse student populations. These positions will be posted in February, and I encourage anyone who has had results in correcting disproportionate outcomes for students to apply.


Closing Slide 11 - Equitable outcomes for all students do not equal disproportionality


I know this Board agrees that equitable outcomes for all students do not equal disproportionality. Today, I have shared quite a bit about the definition of specific learning disability. As these remarks transition to STAR Mid-year data, I want you to remember that the key to eliminating disproportionality and achieving equitable outcomes is understanding who is making progress and at what rate. With this insight, schools can strategically address students' needs while continuing to support those who have already demonstrated grade-level proficiency. As we reach the mid-year mark, the STAR assessment provides a valuable gauge of our progress. The results highlight areas where we can celebrate success and where we must intensify support to accelerate growth toward our goal of "All Means All."


(Presentation Ends)


At this time, I invite Deputy Superintendent Karen Newton-Scott and Assistant Superintendent Jennifer Burton to share our mid-year STAR assessment data and delve deeper into these findings. Winter/Mid-year STAR data Slides Are Available Here


Chair Sulton, I have one additional comment. The Government Finance Officers Association, otherwise known as GFOA, announced that City Schools of Decatur received GFOA's Distinguished Budget Presentation Award for our FY24-25 budget book. The award represents a significant achievement by CSD as it is our first budget book. It also reflects the commitment of the governing body, this Board, and staff to meeting the highest principles of governmental budgeting. In order to receive the budget award, CSD had to satisfy nationally recognized guidelines for effective budget presentation. These guidelines are designed to assess how well our budget serves as a policy document, a financial plan, an operations guide, and a communications device.


Budget documents must be rated "proficient" in all four categories and in the fourteen mandatory criteria within those categories to receive the award. Congratulations to our CFO, Dr. Broome and her team, Chief of Communications, Ms. Hart Murunga, and all of the cabinet who supported the creation of our first budget book and its recognition.

Board Meeting Action/Discussion/Information Items Board Meeting Action/Discussion/Information Items

Financial Audit Report

The District engaged the Mauldin & Jenkins, LLC firm to perform the annual audit. The audit was conducted in accordance with generally accepted governmental accounting standards, and an unmodified opinion (i.e., "clean opinion") was expressed on our financial statements.


The use of a third party or independent auditor ensures a full financial review on an annual basis. The Finance Department then utilizes the information learned from the audit, much like schools use their improvement plans and various assessments, to chart a course for improvement over the rest of the year.


During the fiscal year 2024 audit, the district received no audit findings. A copy of the audit report can be found in the meeting agenda on Simbli.

Consent Items

The board unanimously approved the following consent items:

  • November Financial Reports

  • November School Nutrition Financial Reports

  • December Personnel Report

  • FY25 Mid-year Budget Adjustment

  • Decatur High School PAC Auditorium Seating Replacement

Policy

The board unanimously approved the following policy:

  • Policy BBFB - Governance Teams

Board Policies for Public Comment Board Policies for Public Comment

  • Policy GAMA - Drug-Free Workplace

  • Policy GAMC - Responsibility to Report Criminal Charges to Employer

  • Policy BCBI - Public Participation in Board Meetings

Board of Education Meeting Information Board of Education Meeting Information

Next Regular Board Meeting: The next regular board meeting will be on February 11, 2025

zoom_out_map

Other Upcoming Meetings:

  • HB 581 Public Hearings:

    • Virtual hearing on January 21, 2025, at 6:45 p.m. https://csdecatur.zoom.us/j/95614159391

    • Virtual hearings on January 30, 2025, at 10 a.m. and 6:45 p.m. https://csdecatur.zoom.us/j/95614159391

  • BOE Community Meeting on Wednesday, January 22, 2025, at 6:30 p.m. at Glennwood Elementary

Link to Join Board Meeting Virtually: https://csdecatur.zoom.us/j/95614159391


Board Agenda(s): Go to Simbli to access the CSD Board of Education meeting agenda(s), supporting documents, and meeting minutes.


Public Comments: Click here for information on signing up to speak at a CSD Board meeting.


Contacting Board Members: Email the entire board at board@csdecatur.net. Click here to view board member bios and contact information.


The board values hearing from members of our community. Each Board member reviews and reads all emails sent by our stakeholders.


Georgia law governs school boards, and they cannot intervene in the day-to-day administrative operations of the school district, including direct staff and personnel matters. If you write to us with a concern about district operations, your message will be forwarded to the school or district administrator, who can best address your concern.


The board has also adopted a set of norms that govern our local communication protocols. These include:


1. Emails to individual board members are shared with the entire board.

2. Issues and concerns received by the board and or individual members will be referred to the Superintendent.

3. Board members will follow the chain of command and educate, instruct, and encourage others to do the same.

4. The board chair will reply to emails from constituents sent to all board members. That reply will include the superintendent and other board members on the thread, and the constituent will be informed that the superintendent or their designee will respond to the inquiry/request.

5. Direct all stakeholders' questions, input, or discussion to the Superintendent, who will communicate them as needed to the board.

zoom_out_map

City Schools of Decatur Board of Education

Email: board@csdecatur.net
Website: csdecatur.net
Location: 125 Electric Avenue, Decatur, GA, USA
Phone: (404) 371-3601

CSD Board of Education
Loading indicator

close
Powered by